Ladislaus Josephowitsch Bortkiewicz
St Petersburg, Russia
BiographyLadislaus (or Vladislav) Bortkiewicz's father was Joseph Ivanowitsch Bortkiewicz and his mother was Helene von Rokicka. The family were of Polish descent. Joseph Bortkiewicz came from the Russian nobility. He was a military man with the rank of colonel but he was an instructor teaching artillery and mathematics. In fact he wrote a number of elementary teaching texts on mathematics, economics and finance. Ladislaus certainly was influenced by his father's academic interests.
Bortkiewicz studied law at St Petersburg, graduating in 1890 and then went on to study political economy and statistics for a year of postgraduate work. He studied at Strasbourg from 1891 to 1892, then at Göttingen under Lexis in 1892, going on to also study at Vienna and Leipzig. After submitting a dissertation, he was awarded a doctorate in 1893 from Göttingen.
After lecturing in statistics and actuarial science from 1895 to 1897 as a privatdozent in Strasbourg he went to St Petersburg where he was a clerk in the Railway Office from 1897 until 1901. However, during this time he returned to academic life, teaching statistics from 1899 until December 1900 at the Alexandrowskii Lyceum. Then in 1901 he was appointed as an extraordinary professor of statistics at the University of Berlin. Bortkiewicz became an ordinary professor of statistics and political economy at the University of Berlin in 1920 and he spent the rest of his life there. An unfortunate argument with an Italian statistician Gini, who accused Bortkiewicz of plagiarism, led to an unhappy episode near the end of Bortkiewicz's life.
Bortkiewicz worked on mathematical statistics and applications to actuarial science and political economy. His work on actuarial science was largely concerned with mortality tables. He examined life expectancy in an increasing population and showed in 1893, contrary to what had previously been believed, that life expectancy in such a population could only be computed from mortality tables and was not a function of the observed birth rate and death rate. He published on mortality rates again in publication of 1904 and 1911 where he examined methods to compare mortality rates.
Good, in , argues that the Poisson distribution should have been named the von Bortkiewicz distribution. Bortkiewicz was interested in the law of small numbers and he used the divergence coefficient Q, deducing its expectation and standard deviation. This aspect of Bortkiewicz research is studied in detail in . He published a work The Law of Small Numbers in 1898. In this he was the first to note that events with low frequency in a large population followed a Poisson distribution even when the probabilities of the events varied. Gumbel writes in :-
A striking example was the number of soldiers killed by horse kicks per year per Prussian army corps. Fourteen corps were examined, each for twenty years. For over half the corps-year combinations there were no deaths from horse kicks; for the other combinations the number of deaths ranged up to four. Presumably the risk of lethal horse kicks varied over years and corps, yet the over-all distribution was remarkably well fitted by a Poisson distribution.We also mentioned that Bortkiewicz worked on political economy. Here he examined Marx's theory of profit and prices. He showed that there was an inconsistency in Marx's argument and modified Marx's scheme to make it consistent. Schumpteter writes in :-
By far [Bortkiewicz's] most important achievement is his analysis of the theoretical framework of the Marxian system, much the best thing ever written on it and, incidentally, on its other critics. A similar masterpiece is his paper on the theories of rent of Rodbertus and Marx.Other areas to which Bortkiewicz applied his statistical methods include radioactivity (1913), order statistics, and applications to legal studies.
Bortkiewicz was critical of the approach of Karl Pearson to statistics. He claimed that Pearson produced formulae to match observed results but with no theoretical reasoning. This, claimed Bortkiewicz, was worthless. Keynes however put the other side of the argument when he wrote in his Treatise on probability (1921):-
... Bortkiewicz does not get any less obscure as he goes on. The mathematical argument is right enough and often brilliant. But what it is all really about, and what it really amounts to, and what the premises are, it becomes increasingly perplexing to decide.Sheynin writes in :-
Bortkiewicz was one of the main representatives of the "Continental direction" in mathematical statistics and its application to statistics, but he left no monographs, and the German scientist were only marginally interested in his works. He did not create a school ...Despite writing no monographs, Bortkiewicz did write books and he wrote over 100 papers (some very long) which are listed in . He wrote almost exclusively in German and his works :-
... are distinguished by independent opinions ..., rigorous deductions, and voluminous references of international scope. At the same time, being comprehensive and not accompanied by a summary, they make hard reading.Bortkiewicz received many honours including membership of the Swedish Academy of Sciences, the Royal Statistical Society, the American Statistical Association and the International Statistical Institute.
- O S Sheynin, Biography in Dictionary of Scientific Biography (New York 1970-1990). See THIS LINK.
- O Anderson, Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz, Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie 3 (1931), 242-250.
- T Andersson, Obituary of Ladislaus Josephowitsch Bortkiewicz, Nordic Statistical Journal 3 (1931), 9-26.
- A R Crathorne, The law of small numbers, Amer. Math. Monthly 35 (1928), 169-175.
- I J Good, Some statistical applications of Poisson's work, Statist. Sci. 1 (2) (1986), 157-180.
- E J Gumbel, Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz, International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences 2 (New York, 1968), 128-131.
- M P Quine, and E Seneta, Bortkiewicz's data and the law of small numbers, Internat. Statist. Rev. 55 (2) (1987), 173-181.
- H Schumacher, Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz, Allgemeines statistisches Archiv 21 (1931), 573-576.
- J A Schumpeter, Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz : 1868-1931, in Ten great economists from Marx to Keynes (New York, 1960), 302-305.
- S M Stigler, The History of Statistics. The Measurement of Uncertainty before 1900 (Cambridge, Mass.-London, 1986), 375-376.
Additional Resources (show)
Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update July 2000
Last Update July 2000