Duncan Liddel
Biography
Duncan Liddel was the son of John Liddel who is described in [4] as "a respectable citizen of Aberdeen." We note that Liddel's name sometimes appears as Liddell. He attended schools in Aberdeen where he gained an expertise in languages before entering King's College, Aberdeen, for his university education.Before we continue with Liddel's biography, let us note that all his publications appear to be in medicine with none in mathematics. This is despite the fact that he appears to have been more interested in mathematics than any other topic. John Henry gives a plausible reason in [7]:-
... Liddel wanted to make a career in mathematics, but that, like many others before him, he failed to do so, and turned instead (or, as well) to medicine - which was always, by strong contrast with mathematics, a reliable way to earn a steady, and often lucrative, income. Liddel's polymathy, in short, can be seen as the result of necessity rather than as the untrammelled ranging of an ambitious free spirit. I see Liddel as a mathematician first and foremost ...We present a version of [4] (see also [15] and [16]), which gives a 1790 biography of Liddel, at THIS LINK.
After studying at King's College, Aberdeen, Liddel appears to have been uncertain as to what career he should follow and, in 1579, he left Scotland and travelled to Frankfurt an der Oder, now known as Frankfurt (Oder) a town in Germany close to the Polish border. The University of Frankfurt an der Oder had received its charter from Emperor Maximillian I in 1500 and from Pope Julius II in 1506. By the time that Liddel went there, it had been reformed along the lines of Wittenberg University. There Liddel met fellow Scot, John Craig who influenced him greatly so we should give brief details of John Craig (who must not be confused with the John Craig who has a biography in this archive).
John Craig, the son of the Edinburgh tailor and merchant Robert Craig, had been taught mathematics and astronomy in Frankfurt an der Oder by Paul Wittich. Let us remark that Craig later returned to Scotland and became personal physician to James VI of Scotland (later James I after the union of the crowns of England and Scotland). Craig, although not a particularly good mathematician, is interesting, particularly in the light of a comment by the historian Anthony à Wood (1632-1695) that Napier got the idea for logarithms from a method brought back from the Continent by John Craig. It is certainly possible that the method referred to by Wood is one invented by Wittich since we know that Wittich found how to replace multiplication and division with addition and subtraction using the rules for sines and cosines of the sums and differences of angles. In one of his copies of De revolutionibus, Wittich used the blank space at the end of a chapter to write out an example of his method, known as prosthaphaeresis [2]:-
And this was precisely one of the pages that John Craig had transcribed into his copy of 'De revolutionibus' Ⓣ when he was being tutored by Wittich in Frankfurt an der Oder in 1576. In turn he took his annotated copy with him when he returned to Edinburgh, and he surely must have shown it to Napier who was living in a castle in the area.By October 1579, when Liddel arrived at Frankfurt an der Oder, Wittich was back in Wrocław where he worked with Andreas Dudith. John Craig, however, was still in Frankfurt an der Oder at that time although, after around fifteen years on the Continent, he returned to Scotland around 1582. Craig taught Liddel mathematics, philosophy and medicine. If Liddel had been unsure of what he should do before meeting Craig, there is no doubt that he was quickly convinced by Craig that mathematics was the subject for him. Liddel also [10]:-
... entered the humanist and scientific circle of the Italo-Hungarian man of letters Andreas Dudith-Sbardellati (1533-1589) and the physician Crato von Krafftheim (1519-1585).When Craig was preparing to leave Frankfurt an der Oder, he advised Liddel to go to Wrocław and study with Paul Wittich.
Liddel studied under Wittich at Wrocław for over a year before returning to Frankfurt an der Oder. There he gave private tuition in mathematics and philosophy but, perhaps thinking that this was not going to be a lucrative occupation, continued his study of medicine. In 1587 an epidemic broke out in Frankfurt an der Oder and Liddel left the town, moving to the University of Rostock. It may well be that Liddel went there at the suggestion of John Craig for, Johannes Caselius (1533-1613), the Professor of Rhetoric at Rostock, clearly knew Craig and wrote to him about Liddel. Caselius wrote that Liddel is [4]:-
... an excellent mathematician [in] the more perfect knowledge of the Copernican system, and other astronomical questions. ... Mr Liddel was the first person in Germany, who explained the motions of the heavenly bodies, according to the three different hypotheses of Ptolemy, Copernicus, and Tycho Brahe.George Molland says that Liddel went to meet Tycho Brahe at Uraniborg, on the Danish island of Hveen, at least twice while he was at Rostock [11]:-
Later the friendship [between Liddel and Tycho Brahe] turned to enmity when Brahe came strongly to suspect Liddel of plagiarizing his astronomical system, in which the sun rotated annually around the earth, the moon rotated about the earth, but the other planets circuited the sun. ... Liddel always claimed that he gave Brahe full credit for his system, but he clearly added his own mathematical details, which was probably the source of the confusion.It was Caselius who wrote a letter of recommendation for Liddel to the Academic Senate of Helmstadt, dated 1 January 1591, in which he stressed Liddel's mathematical expertise and his close connection to Brucaeus and his acquaintance with Brahe. On 24 July 1591 Liddel took up employment at the University of Helmstadt and spent many years teaching mathematics there. The University of Helmstadt, known as the Julian Academy after its founder Henry Julius (1564-1613), Duke of Brunswick-Lüneburg, had been founded in October 1576. It was a large Protestant university with four faculties, theology, law, medicine and philosophy. The magnificent auditorium, the Juleum Novum, opened in 1592 shortly after Liddel began teaching there. This wonderful building still stands in Helmstadt. The Julian Academy had two chairs of mathematics, and soon after he came to Helmstadt, Liddel was appointed to the lower of the two chairs. The higher chair was occupied by Erhard Hofmann (1544-1593). Hofmann was the first mathematics professor at the Julian Academy with an annual salary of 100 gold florins. After having given two trial lectures about which a report was sent to the Duke of Brunswick-Lüneburg, Hofmann was appointed professor of mathematics with effect from 22 October 1576. He was admitted to the faculty of philosophy on 25 April 1577 and became dean of the faculty of philosophy six times and vice rector of the university in the winter semester of 1584-85. In 1593 he travelled from the university to settle a border dispute and, on his return journey, fell ill and died in March 1593 at Wolfsburg Castle. After his death, Liddel was promoted to the higher chair of mathematics at Helmstadt in 1593 and Simon Mencius, already the professor of Latin, was appointed to the lower chair. In his first year of teaching in the higher chair Liddel gave the two courses (i) Geometriae fundamenta figurarum usum et geodesiam una cum triangulorum doctrina Ⓣ and (ii) Theoriae coelestium motuum iuxta triplicem hypothesin una cum tabularum tum Alphonsinarum quam Prutenicarum explicatione Ⓣ. For the next nine years [3]:-
... he gave repeated courses of lectures on geometry, astronomy, and universal geography; instructing his pupils in the whole circle of mathematical science, and particularly in the new theories of the planetary system, which until his time were very imperfectly understood or taught in that country.More details of his teaching are given in [10]:-
Professor Liddel's lectures are apparently the most ambitious, as he lectured on advanced scientific books: Tycho Brahe's 'De mundi aetherei recentioribus phaenomenis' (Uraniborg, 1588) for planetary theory and Johannes Regiomontanus's 'Tabulae directionum' Ⓣ for trigonometry. It is also plausible that he used Copernicus's 'De revolutionibus orbium coelestium'Ⓣ, of which he owned two copies, to introduce the heliocentric hypothesis, as announced in the syllabi. Even relative to geography, he sought to integrate classical and modern sources, as he lectured on Pomponius Mela as well as on "histories and descriptions of lands according to the most recent [explorers]" (historia et descriptione regionum secundum recentiores Ⓣ). One can assume that he employed a book like Simon Grynaeus's 'Novus orbis', a collection of reports on Western as well as Oriental countries.He did not only teach mathematics for, in 1596 he obtained an M.D., was admitted to the Faculty of Medicine, and taught in that faculty in addition to his mathematical commitments. He taught in both faculties until 1600 when he resigned his chair of mathematics. It was filled by Heinrich Schaper (1560-1629) who, after the death of Simon Mencius in 1606, held both chairs. Liddel remained in Helmstadt until 1607, but he was involved in another quarrel [10]:-
Liddel was also involved, along with Caselius, the logician Cornelius Martini (1568-1621), and the professor of Aristotelian philosophy Owen Günther (1532-1615) in a quarrel concerning the dignity of philosophy which burst out between 1598 and 1601, after the professor of theology Daniel Hofmann (1538-1611) accused philosophers of being the fathers of all heresies. The polemic, known as the 'Hofmannstreit', ended with the success of the professors of the philosophical faculty against the intransigent theologian, also thanks to the intervention of professors at the University of Rostock and Duke Heinrich Julius. Liddel stayed in Helmstedt until 1607, when he returned to Aberdeen with his mathematical books, among which were two copies of 'De revolutionibus'Ⓣ and a rare handwritten copy of Copernicus's 'Commentariolus' Ⓣ.Back in Scotland, Liddel lived on his estate at Pitmedden, within a few kilometres of Aberdeen. On 12 July 1612 he was at Edinburgh, where he subscribed his first deed of settlement. On 9 December 1613 he executed another deed of settlement this time at Aberdeen. With these settlements, Liddel [13]:-
... left money to found the Chair of Mathematics at Marischal College under the patronage of the Town Council, he left money for bursaries that would enable poor students to attend the College, he donated his extensive library of books on Astronomy, Mathematics and Medicine along with his mathematical instruments to Marischal College, in addition to his estate, and he left money for the Town Council to erect a splendid memorial plaque in St Nicholas Church. Personally, he was never a student of Marischal College (it was founded when he was 32) nor a member of its staff. In return, a large ornamental granite memorial was erected by the Senatus in 1637 on his donated land near Dyce. The monument still stands today in excellent condition. His books, which are now some 400 years old, are an extremely valuable resource among the Historic Collections of the University Library and include a first edition of Copernicus's 'De Revolutionibus' Ⓣ, a copy of Copernicus' very rare 'Commentariolus' Ⓣ and other works from the very early years of modern astronomy.John Stuart writes [4]:-
Dr Liddel, having never been married, left the remainder of his fortune to his brother, John Liddel, and a sister, both of whom had children, and some of whose descendants are still alive in Aberdeen [Note: This was written in 1790]. One son of his brother John is well known to have succeeded Dr William Johnston in the mathematical chair endowed by his uncle; but the young man having acted imprudently, was, according to the author here referred to, most unjustly deprived of his office.
References (show)
- M Feingold (ed.), History of Universities 31 (Oxford University Press, 2019).
- O Gingerich, The book nobody read : Chasing the Revolutions of Nicolaus Copernicus (Arrow Books, London, 2004).
- P Omodeo and K Friedrich (eds.), Duncan Liddel (1561-1613). Networks of Polymathy and the Northern European Renaissance (Brill Academic Publishers, Leiden, 2016).
- J Stuart, A Sketch of the Life of Dr. Duncan Liddel, of Aberdeen, Professor of Mathematics and of Medicine in the University of Helmstadt (J. Chalmers & Co., Aberdeen, 1790).
- R Chalmers, Liddel, (Dr) Duncan, A Biographical Dictionary of Eminent Scotsmen 3 (2) (Blackie & Son, 1837), 437-440.
- A Gibb, Notice of the Memorial Brass of Dr Duncan Liddel, and of the Tombstone of Sir Paul Menzies of Kinmundy, in Saint Nicholas Church, Aberdeen, Proceedings of the Society of Antiquities of Scotland 11 (1876), 450-462.
- J Henry, A pragmatic aspect of polymathy: The alliance of Mathematics and Medicine in Liddel's time, in K Friedrich and P D Omodeo (eds.), Duncan Liddel (1561-1613): Networks of Polymathy and the Northern European Renaissance. Scientific and Learned Cultures and Their Institutions 17 (Brill Academic Publishers, Leiden, 2016). https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/portal/files/18573702/Polymathy_Duncan_Liddel_CMStyle.pdf
- G Molland, Scottish-continental intellectual relations as mirrored in the career of Duncan Liddel (1561-1613), in P Dukes (ed.), The universities of Aberdeen and Europe: the first three centuries (Aberdeen University Press, Aberdeen, 1995), 79-101.
- A G Molland, Duncan Liddell, 1561-1613: an early benefactor of Marischal College library, Aberdeen University Review 51 (1985-86), 485-499.
- D Omodeo, Sixteenth century professors of mathematics at the German University of Helmstadt. A case study on Renaissance scholarly works and networks (Max-Planck-Institut für Wissenschaftsgeschichte, Berlin, 2011). https://www.mpiwg-berlin.mpg.de/Preprints/P417.PDF
- C Platts, revised G Molland, Liddell, Duncan (1561-1613), Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (Oxford University Press, 23 September 2004). https://www.oxforddnb.com/view/10.1093/ref:odnb/9780198614128.001.0001/odnb-9780198614128-e-16639
- A Pyle (ed.), Liddell, Duncan, in The Dictionary of Seventeenth-century British Philosophers (Thoemmes Continuum; Slp edition, 15 April 2000), 517-519.
- J S Reid, Duncan Liddell - astronomical teacher, medic and benefactor of Marischal College, The Scientific Tourist: Aberdeen, University of Aberdeen Homepages. https://homepages.abdn.ac.uk/npmuseum/Scitour/Liddell.pdf
- Significant Scots, Duncan Liddel, Electric Scotland. https://electricscotland.com/history/other/liddel_duncan.htm
- A Sketch of the Life of Dr. Duncan Liddel, of Aberdeen, Professor of Mathematics and of Medicine in the University of Helmstadt, The Aberdeen Magazine; Or, Universal Repository (October 1796), 209-217.
- J Stuart, A Sketch of the Life of Dr. Duncan Liddel, of Aberdeen, Professor of Mathematics and of Medicine in the University of Helmstadt, in Chiefly on Scottish Antiquities (William Bennett, 1846), 42-59.
Additional Resources (show)
Other pages about Duncan Liddel:
Other websites about Duncan Liddel:
Written by
J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update November 2019
Last Update November 2019