Joseph Edward Nelson
Quick Info
Decatur, Georgia, USA
Princeton, New Jersey, USA
Biography
Edward Nelson was the son of Claud Dalton Nelson (1889-1967) and Maud Sparks (1891-1984). Claud Nelson was born near Jacksonville, Arkansas, on 13 July 1889, the son of the Reverend Charley Hestor Nelson and Sara See. He was educated at Hendrix College and at Oxford University, England, where he was the fourth Rhodes Scholar from Arkansas. He became assistant professor of history at Hendrix College and married Maud Sparks in Dallas, Arkansas on 31 December 1914. In October 1916, Claud and Maud Nelson travelled to Petrograd for Y.M.C.A. missionary work in the Russian army. Claud later served with the Y.M.C.A. in France and England. Claud and Maud Nelson had four children, Claud D Nelson Jr (1917-1983), born in Switzerland, James Sparks Nelson (1921-2008), also born in Switzerland, Joseph Edward Nelson (1932-2014), the subject of this biography, and John Nelson. Maud Nelson returned to the United States with her first child and Claud served in Berlin before returning to the United States in 1919.Although Edward Nelson was born in the United States, he was taken to Italy when very young and lived in Rome where his father continued working for the Y.M.C.A. He lived in Italy, which was under the dictatorship of Benito Mussolini, until he was seven years old [12]:-
He remembered even then questioning a children's song that proclaimed Mussolini's infallibility and love for kids. "Ed knew as a 6 year old in Rome that Mussolini was lying. He always said he learned then and there to be a sceptic of any received truth, or authority for authority's sake."Germany invaded Poland on 1 September 1939 and, realising that Italy would soon join Germany, later that month Edward Nelson and his mother returned to Georgia, USA. He had already completed grade 1 in Rome but continued his schooling in Georgia until 1942 when the family moved to New York. He was strongly influenced by his father [12]:-
Nonconformity also ran within Nelson's upbringing. His father was a Methodist minister, Rhodes Scholar, and Southerner who was an early activist for African American civil rights. His father encouraged each of his four sons - in the Jim Crow South - to be nonconformists willing to offer a tired African American woman the front seat of a bus.Coming from Georgia, his New York school insisted that he be put back half a grade and he had to undergo speech therapy. He began his secondary schooling at the Bronx High School of Science in New York but, after the war ended in 1945, he returned with his family to Rome where he attended the Liceo Scientifico Giovanni Verga. After completing his secondary schooling in Rome, he returned to the United States where he enrolled at the University of Chicago.
In 1950 he formulated the problem of the chromatic number of the plane. This asks the question, what is the minimum number of colours required to colour the plane such that no two points at distance 1 from each other have the same colour? He did not publish this question at the time and it was only made widely known when Martin Gardner asked the question in his Mathematical Games column in October 1960. The problem is now known as the Hadwiger–Nelson problem; the Swiss mathematician Hugo Hadwiger (1908-1981) included the problem in a collection of problems he published in 1961. It has been known since 2018 that the chromatic number of the plane is at least 5 and at most 7 but the exact number is still unknown.
Nelson was awarded an M.S. from Chicago in 1953 and he continued to undertake research for a Ph.D. advised by Irving Segal. Nelson said [1]:-
I was introduced to probability theory in a graduate course taught by Irving Segal from galley proofs of Doob's "Stochastic Processes". Irving presented his own viewpoint in addition to Doob's, and it was an exciting course. Once he drove me down to Urbana so we could talk with Doob. It was a memorable trip. Maintaining that the probability of an accident is directly proportional to the time spent on the road, Irving drove in such a way as to minimise that time. Despite having Irving Segal as thesis adviser, I did not learn physics at the University of Chicago. I took one course in the physics department but was defeated by the lab; I didn't really know how to explain the 457 percent error in my result for the mechanical equivalent of heat.Nelson submitted his thesis On the operator theory of Markoff processes to the University of Chicago in September 1955. The thesis contains the following Acknowledgements:-
This research was done while the author held a National Science Foundation Fellowship. The author is greatly indebted to Professor I E Segal for inspiration and many helpful suggestions during the course of this work. Thanks are also due to Professors Halmos and Bahadur for their patient and critical reading of the text.In the Introduction to the thesis he writes:-
Banach space techniques have long been applied to the study of Markov processes. Kakutani and Yosida obtained the best results on the Markov processes for which the uniform ergodic theorem holds by elegant operator-theoretic methods, and discovered the mean ergodic theorem on reflexive Banach spaces. More recently, the theory of semigroups has been applied to diffusion processes. In the following pages some applications of operator theory to Markov processes will be made in new directions.There was conscription in the USA in the 1950s and Nelson was a conscientious objector. He therefore had to spend two years working in the Methodist Hospital of Gary, Indiana, as his contribution to the draft.
In October 1956 he submitted the paper An existence theorem for second order parabolic equations to the American Mathematical Society. This paper was essentially part of his thesis. Also in October 1956 he became a NSF Postdoctoral Fellow in the School of Mathematics and the School of Natural Sciences at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. He continued to hold this position until 1959 when he was appointed as an Assistant Professor at Princeton University. The years at the Institute for Advanced Study were very productive ones for Nelson and he had nine papers in print by 1959.
Let us note at this point that the paper Expectations of functionals on a stochastic process (1960) by Edward Nelson and Dale Varberg is shown in error by MathSciNet as a paper by the Edward Nelson of this biography. This paper, however, is written by a different Edward Nelson who was awarded a Ph.D. from the University of Minnesota in 1959.
Nelson married Nancy Wong Nelson (1930-1988) after the award of his M.S. Nancy, who was born in Chicago, received a bachelor's degree from the University of Chicago and an Ed.D. degree from Rutgers University. Edward and Nancy Nelson had two children, Kathleen Nelson, who became Kathleen Peterson after her marriage, and Douglas Wong Nelson (1961-2023), born in Victoria, Hong Kong.
Edward Nelson was promoted to Associate Professor at Princeton University in 1962 and in 1964 became a full professor. He explains in [1] how Arthur Wightman influenced him when he moved to Princeton:-
... when I got to Princeton University, I attended several of Arthur Wightman's courses and pored over the papers of Richard Feynman and Kurt Symanzik, and after a while I began to learn the difference between a Lagrangian and a Hamiltonian.He wrote the important papers A quartic interaction in two dimensions (1966) and Construction of quantum fields from Markoff fields (1973) which led to him receiving the 1995 Steele Prize for Seminal Contribution to Research from the American Mathematical Society [1]:-
In these papers he showed for the first time how to use the powerful tools of probability theory to attack the hard analytic questions of constructive quantum field theory, controlling renormalisations with estimates in the first paper and, in the second, turning Euclidean quantum field theory into a subset of the theory of stochastic processes.You can read the full citation for this award and Nelson's response at THIS LINK.
Related to Nelson's work in this area four books he published: Dynamical theories of Brownian motion (1967), Tensor Analysis (1967), Topics in dynamics. I: Flows (1969), and Quantum fluctuations (1985). The first three of these books are based on graduate lecture courses that he delivered at Princeton University. The fourth, Quantum fluctuations, was given in Switzerland. He writes in the Preface:-
These are the revised lecture notes of a course given in June, 1983 for the Troisième cycle de la physique en Suisse romande Ⓣ. This course was given at a time when my thinking about stochastic mechanics was in a state of flux.Eric A Carlen writes [3]:-
This stimulating book is a concise survey of stochastic mechanics, a subject whose development was largely initiated by the author's earlier book [Dynamical theories of Brownian motion (1967)]. The present book is full of original approaches to problems old and new in both mathematics and physics.John L Challifour writes in [5]:-
For myself, this volume of lecture notes presents the foreground between stochastic mechanics and quantum mechanics with clarity, economy, and elegance - virtues that I have come to expect from Nelson's writing.In [12] we learn that these books, based on Nelson's graduate courses, although wonderful, cannot convey to the reader what it was like for the students who attended these courses:-
Ed served for a number of years as director of graduate studies, reflecting his deep commitment to graduate education. He polished four of his graduate courses into books published in the Mathematical Notes series by Princeton University Press. The books are truly marvellous but cannot capture the verve and originality of Ed's teaching. One of the books, 'Tensor Analysis', based on a course he gave on differential geometry, includes a theorem that says - literally - that it is possible to park in any parking space just slightly longer than your car if you use enough iterations of the parallel parking manoeuvre. To do this, one would like to be able to "slide" sideways into the parking place. Ed modelled the configuration space of the car as a certain four-dimensional manifold and studied the interactions of four vector fields on this manifold, showing how "steer" and "drive" could be used to produce "wriggle" and then "slide." It is enormously fun reading, for mathematicians anyhow, but it had a serious purpose as an introduction to the subject of "holonomy." As delightful as the version in the book is, the version in class was illustrated with a toy car Ed purchased at the Woolworth's, then on Nassau Street, for this purpose. He got a "sitting ovation" at the end of his lecture!For more information about these four books, see THIS LINK.
Nelson spend several periods at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton. Following the 1956-59 period mentioned above he was a Member of the School of Natural Sciences at the Institute for Advanced Study for the periods: August 1963 - July 1964; September 1967 - June 1968; and September 1973 - June 1974. He made one further visit to the Institute for Advanced Study but this was to the School of Mathematics and was from September 1979 to September 1980. The fact that this visit was to the School of Mathematics was significant since Nelson was changing the area of his research interests. He had changed to work in mathematical logic, after coming to the conclusion that standard mathematical reasoning contained unjustifiable semantic elements [22]:-
I must relate how I lost my faith in Pythagorean numbers. One morning at the 1976 Summer Meeting of the American Mathematical Society in Toronto, I woke early. As I lay meditating about numbers, I felt the momentary overwhelming presence of one who convicted me of arrogance for my belief in the real existence of an infinite world of numbers, leaving me like an infant in a crib reduced to counting on my fingers. Now I live in a world in which there are no numbers save those that human beings on occasion construct.The work that he began at the Institute for Advanced Study became the material for a graduate course at Princeton in the following year, then became the book Predicative arithmetic (1986). He explains in this book the problems he sees with mathematical induction and introduces this in a section The impredicativity of induction. Put simply, perhaps too simply, Nelson does not believe that the infinite set of natural numbers exists, and only believes in the unbounded finite number of natural numbers that we have constructed.
You can read part of this section at THIS LINK.
We learn several interesting things about Nelson and his move to mathematical logic from the articles [31]:-
In terms of religion, I'm a Christian. Worship and prayer are very important to me. I experience religion more as a matter of faith than of a belief system, and I think there's one question where mathematics and monotheistic faith seemingly conflict, and that is in the nature of mathematical objects. Let's take the numbers, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and so forth - 0 too. But also more general mathematical objects, like exotic spheres and whatnot. Do these things exist? Well, as a formalist I believe that we make them. But if we believe that the numbers, 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 exist as a completed infinity, where did they come from? Have they existed as they were in the beginning or now and ever shall be? That sounds like a religious belief - not mine. If we believe they're created, that raises a problem, because I believe it's part of monotheistic faith that all of creation is contingent; it could have been created otherwise. How could the numbers have been created otherwise? I think there's a real problem here.He said he believed that one day someone would prove, using the number theory axioms, that 0 = 1. He said that he was working on it and thought he's manage it in the next couple of years. On 26 September 2011, Nelson posted what he believed was a contradiction in Peano arithmetic:-
...
I describe myself as an extreme formalist. That means that David Hilbert, who is regarded as the founder of formalism, I think was in his heart a Platonist. I believe he adopted formalism as a strategy against his antagonist, the intuitionist, L E J Brouwer. For example, he set the programme of proving that mathematics was consistent, starting with number theory, to prove that number theory was consistent. Well, that's a mistake. The question is: is elementary number theory consistent or not? I believe it's not. I believe that we do not have certainty in mathematics. I believe that many of the things we regard as being established in mathematics will be overthrown. And I'm a crackpot in that respect.
I am writing up a proof that Peano arithmetic (P), and even a small fragment of primitive-recursive arithmetic (PRA), are inconsistent. This is posted as a Work in Progress ...After postings by Terence Tao and replies by Nelson, on 29 September 2011, Terence Tao produced an argument to which Nelson replied on 1 October:-
You are quite right, and my original response was wrong. Thank you for spotting my error. I withdraw my claim.Nelson was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences in 1975, elected to the National Academy of Sciences in 1997, elected a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in 2003 and elected a fellow of the American Mathematical Society in 2012. After Nelson retired in 2013 he reflected on his career in [21]:-
Teaching freshman calculus is fun, but it poses very different challenges from graduate teaching. ... The most rewarding kind of teaching is the direction of Ph.D. theses.He also writes about administration [21]:-
I was the department's first webmaster, constructing the protocols, all but the final step of getting an IP address, to connect us to the World Wide Web. But the most rewarding administrative experience I had was one year when I was director of graduate studies. I would interview each graduate student. Michael O'Nan was one of them; this was back in the old Fine Hall. Something in his demeanour prompted me to call him back as he was about to leave. It turned out that he was unhappy with the thesis problem in analysis he had been assigned; what he really wanted to work on was finite groups. There was no one in the department who could advise such a thesis. I made some phone calls (there was no email then) and arranged for him to work with Daniel Gorenstein. Michael's thesis was an essential step in the classification of finite simple groups.Nelson's wife Nancy Wong Nelson died on 18 January 1988. In 1990 he married Sarah Jones. Nelson died due to complications from lymphoma in 2014 at the age of 82. His long time friend and colleague Simon Kochen described his character [15]:-
He was a man full of convictions and a lot of things he did went against the grain of other mathematicians. Although Ed had an unassuming presence, you mustn't mistake that for softness. He had a will of steel. He was really courageous. He had a strong conviction and was a strong enough mathematician that he could put his ideas into practice.In 2020 one of his granddaughters posted the following tribute on Instagram:-
Six years ago today, this world lost one of the greatest men (and minds) its ever seen. Amazing is an understatement when trying to describe Edward Nelson - his contributions to mathematics and science made him a legend to the world, his sheer awesomeness made him a legend to anyone who ever met him. I am the luckiest girl ever to have had a man of such greatness play one of the most influential roles in my life. I am grateful my children had the opportunity to know him. He taught me the meaning of compassion, humility, strength, determination and unconditional love. May you rest in peace dearest Granddad and celebrate eternity with your true love Mahnyo (Nancy Wong Nelson). I love you so much.
References (show)
- 1995 Steele Prizes, Notices of the American Mathematical Society 42 (11) (1995), 1288-1292.
- M Aizenman, S Kochen, E Lieb, B Simon and R Gunning, Edward Nelson (1932-2014), Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://www.math.princeton.edu/people/edward-nelson - E A Carlen, Review: Quantum fluctuations, by Edward Nelson, Mathematical Reviews MR0783254 (86f:81039).
- Celebrating the work of Prof Edward Nelson (1932-2014), 22 April 2015, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://www.math.princeton.edu/news/celebrating-work-prof-edward-nelson-1932-2014-april-22-2015 - J L Challifour, Review: Quantum fluctuations, by Edward Nelson, Science, New Series 229 (4714) (1985), 645-646.
- Claud Dalton Nelson, Daily Arkansas Gazette (Thursday 31 December 1914).
- Conway man coming home from Berlin, Arkansas Democrat (Thursday 18 September 1919).
- C Dimitracopoulos, Review: Predicative arithmetic, by Edward Nelson, Mathematical Reviews MR0869999 (88c:03061).
- J L Doob, Review: Dynamical theories of Brownian motion, by Edward Nelson, The Annals of Mathematical Statistics 39 (20 (1968), 686.
- Douglas Wong Nelson (October 1, 1961 - October 27, 2023), Grieco Funerals (2005).
https://www.griecofunerals.com/obituaries/douglas-nelson - Edward Nelson CV, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/cv.pdf - Edward Nelson, Dean of the Faculty, Princeton University (2025).
https://dof.princeton.edu/people/edward-nelson - Edward Nelson Obituary, Town Topics, Princeton's Weekly Newspaper (1 October 2014).
https://www.towntopics.com/2014/10/01/obituaries-10114/ - M G Katz and S S Kutateladze, Edward Nelson, Review of Symbolic Logic 8 (3) (2015), 607-610.
- M Kelly, Edward Nelson, nonconformist who sparked a quantum field theory revolution, dies at 82, Princeton University (2025).
https://www.princeton.edu/news/2014/09/19/edward-nelson-nonconformist-who-sparked-quantum-field-theory-revolution-dies-82 - G Lawler, Comments on Edward Nelson's "Internal set theory: a new approach to nonstandard analysis", Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society (N.S.) 48 (4) (2011), 503-506.
- T L Lindström, Review: Radically elementary probability theory (1987), by Edward Nelson, Mathematical Reviews MR0906454 (88k:60001).
- H P McKean Jr, Review: Dynamical theories of Brownian motion, by Edward Nelson, Mathematical Reviews MR0214150 (35 #5001).
- Missionary to Russians, Daily Arkansas Gazette (Friday 13 October 13 1916).
- Nancy Wong Nelson, 1983B, PTS Alumni/ae News (Winter 1989), 23.
- E Nelson, Reflections on retirement, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/papers/retirement.pdf - E Nelson, Mathematics and Faith, Jubilee for Men and Women from the World of Learning, The Vatican, 23-24 May 2000.
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/papers/faith.pdf - E Nelson, Mathematics and the Mind, Toward a Science of Consciousness - Fundamental Approaches, Tokyo, 25-28 May 1999.
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/papers/tokyo.pdf - E Nelson, Understanding Intuitionism, Rencontre du Reseau Georges Reeb, 24-28 March 1997.
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/papers/int.pdf - E Nelson, Space-Time-Chance, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://web.math.princeton.edu/~nelson/papers/cti.html - Professor Emeritus Edward Nelson Passed Away September 10th, Department of Mathematics, Princeton University (2025).
https://www.math.princeton.edu/news/professor-emeritus-edward-nelson-passed-away-september-10th - P Pudlák, Review: Predicative arithmetic, by Edward Nelson, The Journal of Symbolic Logic 53 (3) (1988), 987-989.
- G A Reid, Review: Tensor Analysis, by Edward Nelson, The Mathematical Gazette 54 (387) (1970), 99-100.
- C Robinson, Review: Topics in dynamics. I: Flows, by Edward Nelson, Mathematical Reviews MR0282379 (43 #8091).
- A J Wilkie, Review: Predicative arithmetic, by Edward Nelson, Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society 22 (2) 1990), 326-331.
- Mathematics and Religion, The Philoctetes Center (17 October 2009).
http://philoctetes.org/documents/Mathematics_and_Religion.pdf
Additional Resources (show)
Other pages about Edward Nelson:
Other websites about Edward Nelson:
Honours (show)
Honours awarded to Edward Nelson
Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update September 2025
Last Update September 2025