Henry George Forder

Quick Info

27 September 1889
Shotesham All Saints, near Norwich, England
21 September 1981
Selwyn Village, Port Chevalier, Auckland, New Zealand

Henry Forder was a New Zealand mathematician who worked in geometry.


Henry Forder's parents were Mary Ann Chilvers and Henry Forder, a joiner, blacksmith, farrier and wheelwright. Henry was the eldest of his parent's six children, having three brothers and two sisters. Henry Forder Sr. bought the village blacksmith's business in Worstead, Norfolk, and the family moved there when Henry was young. One might have expected that a tradesman's family would have little appreciation for learning, but this was certainly not the case. In fact Henry Forder Sr. loved books and his son Henry, the subject of this biography, read avidly as a child, continuing this throughout his life. Henry was fortunate in several ways which enabled him to obtain a first class education. Firstly the headmaster of the local Worstead church school which he attended realised that Henry was an exceptionally gifted boy and gave him special tuition. Secondly, county scholarships were introduced in 1902 to allow gifted children to obtain a better education. Encouraged by the headmaster and by his family, Henry won a scholarship which enabled him to attend Paston Grammar School, about 5 km from his home [4]:-
At Paston he was exposed to the rich world of classical scholarship and to the contrasting world of modern philosophical and scientific speculation. While his facility with languages was nurtured at this school, his mathematical development flourished to some extent independently of the school. Although he was greatly influenced by some gifted mathematics teachers, his own ability was of such an order that he was able to work most successfully unaided.
We know a lot about Paston Grammar School since the Venerable Archdeacon Charles R Forder, who was Henry's youngest brother, wrote a history of the school. Henry, together with another pupil, founded the school debating society in 1907 and Henry took part in debates on topics such as conscription, female suffrage, the House of Lords and the justifiability of Mary Queen of Scots' execution. He won a scholarship from Norfolk County Council to study at the University of Cambridge and this was augmented with further support from the Governors of Paston School and by Sidney Sussex College. He also won many prizes from the school and he chose himself the books Lay Sermons by Thomas Henry Huxley, The Essays of Elia by Charles Lamb, Poems by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow, Poems by John Milton, Vanity Fair by William Makepeace Thackeray, and Oliver Cromwell by John Morley.

Forder matriculated at Sidney Sussex College on 2 October 1907. He was ranked first class in Part I of the Mathematical Tripos of 1908 (and was awarded a further scholarship for his performance) and, two years later, was a Wrangler (First Class) in Part II. He would have liked to remain at Cambridge to continue to a research career, but lack of finance forced him to give up this idea. He then chose the profession that he wanted to follow and became a mathematics master. He taught at Hulme grammar school in Oldham, Lancashire, from 1910 to July 1913, then at Cardiff High School, next at St Olave's School in London, and finally at Hymers' College in Hull, Yorkshire. His brother Charles (who we mentioned above) wrote [9]:-
When I was vicar in Hull, 1947-57, I met many of his former pupils from Hymers' College, and all remembered him with affection.
In 1921, while Forder was teaching at Hymers' College, he married his cousin Dorothy Whincup of Bingham, Nottinghamshire; they had no children. By 1933 Forder had become somewhat dissatisfied with teaching so when he was invited to apply for the Chair of Mathematics at Auckland University College in New Zealand he put in an application. One of the referee's for his application, Arthur Milne, wrote in his report:-
Forder is extremely widely read in mathematical logic and philosophy, pure mathematics, relativity, quantum mechanics and astrophysics, and on these subjects I have heard him speak with knowledge, and authority, and with marked originality.
He was not, of course, the only applicant; his main rival was Keith Bullen. G H Hardy was asked to give an opinion on all the applicants and wrote of Forder that he [8]:-
... is plainly, in his way, a rather remarkable man, since he combines so much experience of comparatively elementary teaching with a real understanding of and enthusiasm for the logic of his subject .... I bought his book [Foundations of Euclidean Geometry (1927)] ... and read quite a lot of it, and was genuinely interested by it.
Forder spent the rest of his career in the Chair of Mathematics at Auckland. In fact he only once left New Zealand after settling there, this being in 1947 when he spent part of his leave in England. He spent 21 years building up the Mathematics Department at Auckland from a Department of a professor with one assistant when he arrived to one of six staff by the time he retired in 1955. Nield writes [8]:-
The mathematical syllabus which Forder found when he arrived at Auckland shocked him. After one term he was invited to report to Council. He wrote that he would attempt to raise the standard at Auckland to the standard of the scholarship examinations taken in schools in England. He reported that it was at present possible for a student to get First Class Honours and be completely unaware of the existence of the whole of modern mathematics, and by modern mathematics he meant not the mathematics of this century but the last! Such was the inertia of the University of New Zealand system, coupled with the political need to cater for large numbers of part-time and exempt students, that it took him until 1936 to get the theory of complex variables into the course, and until 1938 to get calculus into the syllabus for Pure Mathematics I.
It is the books that Forder wrote which have given him a high reputation in the mathematical world. These are: The Foundations of Euclidean Geometry (1927), A School Geometry (1930), Higher Course Geometry (1931), The Calculus of Extension (1941), Geometry (1950), and Coordinates in Geometry (1953). In the Preface to the first of these, Forder writes:-
Although the Euclidean geometry is the oldest of the sciences and has been studied critically for over two thousand years, it seems there is no textbook which gives a connected and rigorous account of that doctrine in the light of modern investigations. It is hoped that this book will fill the gap.
F W Owens [11] feels that he succeeds:-
There may be a difference of opinion on the question of the completeness of the gap filling, but Mr Forder has written an interesting book and one which should be welcomed by those interested in seeing the rigour of modern analysis achieved in geometrical studies.
Dover Publications produced an unabridged and unaltered republication of the 1927 book in 1958. The Calculus of Extension (1941) is in many ways the most interesting of all Forder's books. He explains in the Preface how he came to write the book:-
This book had its origin when Professor Neville in 1929 passed on to me some papers left to the Mathematical Association by Professor Genese. These contained lecture notes and examples on Grassmann's methods. Though the notes themselves have been used but little, a large number of examples from this source have been incorporated in the earlier chapters. As I had been interested in this field for years, I thought it might be worthwhile to extend the work beyond the strictly elementary field covered in Genese's notes, and give a coherent account of Grassmann's methods, with a number of applications sufficient to justify their use. The emphasis on identities is my own, and my aim has been to express geometric theorems as identities, involving not coordinates but the geometric entities themselves which appear in the theorems. ... The algebra of vectors created by Grassmann and Hamilton has at last won an established place in physics. Grassmann's methods are of equal use in geometry, but this application is less widely appreciated. It is hoped that this book will redress the balance.
The book was reviewed by Eduard Helly who writes:-
The book is the first modern textbook of Grassmann's calculus of extension. It gives a very lucid account of Grassmann's original methods and of the investigations of other mathematicians who continued his work.
H V Craig [5] writes:-
Forder's 'The calculus of extension' not only presents a wealth of specific applications of the subject to geometry, that are either new or not readily obtainable elsewhere; but in addition furnishes an admirable and fresh exposition of the 'Ausdehnungslehre'. It is very carefully written and the individual proofs are uniformly short and easy to follow. The theorem density is exceptionally high and consequently despite the superior exposition it is not an easy book to work straight through - perhaps the key chapters suffer from lack of recapitulation. Books that contain a wealth of material are never easy to read through, and it is my conviction that The calculus of extension provides the best exposition of the fundamental processes of the 'Ausdehnungslehre' and the most inclusive treatment of the geometrical applications available at present. It is a book that should be in the library of anyone who is interested in either algebra, the algebraic treatment of geometry, or vector and tensor analysis.
Geometry (1950) was reviewed by Donald Coxeter who was clearly fascinated by Forder's use of language:-
The two-cusped epicycloid is described as the bright curve seen "when the sun shines on a cup of tea." ... The chapter on logical structure stresses the abstract nature of the order relation (ABC) by comparing it with the human relation "A prefers C to B." The possibility of coordinatising any descriptive geometry of three or more dimensions is epitomized in the statement that "we can create magnitudes from a mere muchness," and Archimedes' axiom in the statement that "you will always reach home, if you walk long enough."
Coordinates in Geometry (1953) was reviewed by Marshall Hall, Jr who writes:-
There are three chapters in this monograph. In the first there is an elegant presentation of the consequences of the minor theorem of Desargues and its equivalence to coordinates from an alternative division ring. This leads naturally to the full theorem of Desargues and associative coordinates. The second chapter, without axioms of order deals with congruence of angles (crosses) and line segments (point pairs) in a Pappian geometry. The third chapter uses properties of convex functions to develop the trigonometry of the hyperbolic plane.
Of course Forder's love of language was closely related to his love of books which we have mentioned already. He showed this love in many ways, not least in building a fine mathematics library in large part with funds he supplied himself. His love of books extended to books of a wide range of subjects [8]:-
Of course Forder continued to read lots of books, particularly on history. He made a point of telling Rutherford, the Professor of History, that he read history when he was too tired to read mathematics, and he took a delight in correcting colleagues who, in the course of conversation in the Senior Common Room, made slips of historical fact. Indeed, Forder was renowned as a wit and conversationist. In his entry in Who's Who in New Zealand he listed his interests as "walking and talking", and the latter predominated.
Butcher [4] asks if Forder was a good teacher:-
Students who wanted nothing more than a set of notes to swot up for exams would have said not. Students who were themselves mathematicians and scientists in the making would have said that he was. For these people, he was more than a good teacher, he was a brilliant teacher. While a good set of notes can be copied from a textbook, an insight into what mathematics is certainly cannot, and that is exactly what he gave to those who were prepared to receive this insight. He loved mathematics with a burning intensity and most of all he loved geometry. You had to share this with him or, intellectually speaking, you had to part company with him.
D A Nield writes about the lectures by Forder which he attended in the final three years that Forder taught at Auckland University:-
I remember him as one of medium height and build, slightly stooped, with a roundish face of florid complexion surmounted by short white hair, wearing glasses with round lenses and thin metal frames which, from time to time, he used to raise in order to peer at his lecture notes. These were usually written in an extremely concise format in small notebooks from which the staples had been removed.
Finally let us record some of the honours which Forder received. He was elected a fellow of the Royal Society of New Zealand (1947), the University of Auckland awarded him an honorary D.Sc. in 1959 and the book [1] commemorates his eightieth birthday. The Mathematical Chronicle published a H G Forder 90th birthday volume in 1980.

References (show)

  1. J C Butcher (ed.), A spectrum of mathematics : Essays presented to H G Forder (Oxford University Press, London, 1971).
  2. G Ardley, Professor H G Forder: the later years : H G Forder 90th birthday volume, Math. Chronicle 9 (1980), 1-2.
  3. Bibliography of the works of H G Forder, in J C Butcher (ed.), A spectrum of mathematics : Essays presented to H G Forder (Oxford University Press, London, 1971), 235-238.
  4. J C Butcher, Obituary: Henry George Forder, Bull. London Math. Soc. 17 (2) (1985), 162-167.
  5. H V Craig, Review: Henry George Forder, The calculus of extension, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 49 (7) (1943), 524-527.
  6. J A Kalman, Henry George Forder, New Zealand Math. Mag. 18 (2) (1981/82), 46-49.
  7. P Lorimer, CENTREFOLD : Professor Henry Forder, New Zealand Math. Soc. Newsletter 19 (December 1980).
  8. D A Nield, Professors of Mathematics at Auckland University College
  9. The Missionary, the Businessman, the Story-teller and the Salesman, New Zealand Math. Soc. Newsletter 27 (April 1983).
  10. B H Neumann, Forder, Henry George (1889-1981), Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (Oxford University Press, 2004). See THIS LINK.
  11. Obituary: Professor H G Forder, Math. Chronicle 11 (1-2) (1982), 122-123.
  12. F W Owens, Review: Henry George Forder, The Foundations of Euclidean Geometry, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 35 (6) (1929), 881-882.
  13. D Robb, Henry George Forder, in J C Butcher (ed.), A spectrum of mathematics : Essays presented to H G Forder (Oxford University Press, London, 1971), 11-15.
  14. C M Segedin, Henry George Forder - an appreciation, New Zealand Math. Mag. 18 (2) (1981/82), 42-46.
  15. C Series, Notes from a Forder Lecturer, London Math. Soc. Newsletter (April 2004).
  16. R E Swenson, Bibliography of recent works of H G Forder : H G Forder 90th birthday volume, Math. Chronicle 9 (1980), 3-4.

Additional Resources (show)

Cross-references (show)

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update February 2010