Henri Paul Mineur

Quick Info

7 March 1899
Lille, France
7 May 1954
Paris, France

Henri Mineur was a French astronomer and mathematician who observed the variation of star movements based on their distance from the core of a galaxy.


Henri Mineur's parents were Paul Mineur and Léonie Jacquet. Paul Mineur was a mathematics teacher who was teaching in Lille at the time when his son Henri was born. He later moved to Paris where he taught at the Collège Rollin (which was renamed the Lycée Rollin in 1919 and, since 1944 has been known as the Lycée Jacques-Decour). Henri received all his schooling in Paris at the Collège Rollin where he showed remarkable talents in mathematics. Jean Claude Barthélemy Dufay (1896-1967), the author of [5], although three years older than Mineur, was a pupil at the Collège Rollin at the same time. He also became a well-known astronomer holding posts such as director of the Lyon Observatory and of Haute-Provence Observatory. Daniel Barbier [3] writes:-
This very young Henri is interested in astronomy. Possessing a 75mm telescope, he builds himself an equatorial telescope. We find in 'L'Astronomie' evidence of his modest observations when he was 15 to 16 years old and which relate to the sun, planets, double stars and variable stars; at the meeting of 6 February 1916, the Secretary General of the Astronomical Society, Camille Flammarion, reported having received a minor note, 'Détermination du méridien avec un plan à plomb et une montre non réglée' and raising his hands to heaven exclaimed, "It's full of sines in there." Mineur had, indeed, discovered mathematics.

While still at High School, preparing for the second part of his degree, Henri Mineur had developed a passion for functional equations. Notes that he wrote at that time, which were kept by one of his classmates, demonstrate a keen and even extraordinary mathematical sense in a young man of 17 years. There are remarks such as "the superiority of functional equations over differential equations is that they allow one to define discontinuous functions."
In 1917 Mineur took the highly competitive examinations for admission to the École Polytechnique and the École Normale Supérieur in Paris. He was ranked highly for the École Polytechnique and ranked first for the École Normale Supérieur, which he then chose for his studies. However, because of World War I, he decided to join the army in which he served until 1919. Two years in the army did not hold up his progress for long for he was awarded his first degree (l'agrégation) in 1921. He had already started research in mathematics by 1920 and, after graduating, he taught mathematics in the Lycée Français, a school in Dusseldorf, Germany, while he was completing his thesis. He was awarded his doctorate in 1924 for his thesis Discontinuous solutions of a class of functional equations in which he established an addition theorem for Fuchsian functions. The work of his thesis was published in 1925 as was the paper Théorie analytique des groupes continus finis and, three years later, he published a paper on the absolute differential calculus Calcul différentiel absolu .

We have already noted that Mineur had been interested in astronomy from a young age and in 1925 he left teaching to take up the post of "astronomer adjoint" in the Paris Observatory. In fact he had worked at the Paris Observatory a few years earlier, being a trainee there in 1922-23. Mineur married Suzanne Fromant in 1926 and then remarried to Gabrielle Cloche in 1929. Her picture of Mineur is very different from the one presented in obituaries and we quote from her at the end of this biography.

Mineur contributed to many areas of astronomy and mathematics including celestial mechanics, analytic mechanics, statistics and numerical analysis. Examples of his papers around 1930 are Sur les ondes de gravitation (1928) and La mécanique des masses variables. Le problème des deux corps (1933). In 1938 he wrote an important work on the least square method, Technique de la méthodes des moindres carrés . Arthur H Copeland writes:-
Mineur states in the preface of his book that it should be possible for the reader to learn to use the method of least squares without understanding the theory behind it. In fact, the theory of the various operations is not fully explained until the fifth chapter. For this reason the mathematician will perhaps find it more satisfactory to proceed directly from the first chapter to the fifth and then read the second, third, and fourth.
His most important work on numerical methods was Technique de calcul numérique (1952). William Edmund Milne begins a review of the text as follows:-
There are few general treatises, and until now none in French, devoted to methods of interpolation and procedures for numerical calculation. The aim of the present work is to make available to others the practical experience of the author, who, as an astronomer, was led to study methods of calculation and as director of a mathematical research laboratory for national defence had further occasion to solve many numerical problems. The text is addressed not only to mathematicians but also to astronomers, physicists, engineers and others who encounter numerical calculations. The author's plan of presentation is to divide each chapter or subdivision of a chapter into three parts, first theory, second technique, and third numerical applications. The theoretical part provides the derivation of the necessary mathematical formulas, the technique indicates the program by which the problem is set up as well as the organized routine for performing the calculation, and the numerical applications illustrate by specific examples the actual operation of the process.
In astronomy Mineur made many significant discoveries. He worked on the propagation of gravitational waves, the evolution of double stars and the proper motions of the stars. He discovered that the speeds of the stars varied according to their distance from the plane of the galaxy. He also discovered the retrograde rotation of the system of globular clusters around the galaxy and corrected the coordinates for the position of the galactic centre. His most significant astronomical discovery was to realise that there was an error in the accepted period-luminosity law for Cepheid variables and he published his revised version in Zéro de la relation période-luminosité (1944). Since the whole scale of the Universe is based on distances determined using this relationship, this discovery doubled the size of the Universe in the sense that all objects in the Universe were now shown to be twice as far away as previously thought. This had a huge impact for cosmology and, although ill at the time, he was able to attend the meeting in Rome in 1952 where Walter Baade announced independent confirmation of Mineur's scale for the universe. Mineur explained his work in this area in the book L'espace interstellaire (1947) which also contained details of his research into interstellar absorption. Earlier, in 1933, he had published L'Univers en Expansion which [10]:-
... is a good collection of the results obtained by the Lemaître-Eddington-de Sitter line of development of the theory of the "expanding universe."
Willem Jacob Luyten also reviews the same text, writing in [9]:-
It gives one of the very few up-to-date discussions of the subject, which is not merely intended for the layman or the general public, but treats the entire problem concisely, "from the ground up," using directly the equations of Einstein, de Sitter, Lemaître, and others, and discusses the properties of the various types of space resulting from each. It closes with a résumé of Eddington's calculations of the Cosmological constant l. It is clearly written, and gives an admirable summary of this 'question brulante' of the present, and may be heartily recommended to any one interested in the problem.
Mineur published Histoire de l'astronomie stellaire jusqu'à l'époque contemporaine in 1934. This 57 page pamphlet looked at topics such as: The ancient world and medieval astronomy; Galileo and his successors; Birth of stellar astronomy; William Herschel; The first half of the XIXth century; The late nineteenth century and the early modern period; Large modern instruments; and Photograph of the sky. In 1936 the service for research in astrophysics was set up comprising of the Observatoire de Haute Provence and a laboratory in Paris. Later, in 1939, this became part of the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS). Mineur, together with Daniel Chalonge, was the main force behind the setting up of this service. Mineur was Secretary General of this service and director of the Paris laboratory but he was removed from these positions by the Vichy government after the fall of France during World War II. After the war he became director of the Institute d'Astrophysique in Paris, a post he held for the rest of his life.

During the years 1940-44 Mineur was an active member of the French Resistance risking his life on many occasions. Barbier writes [2]:-
A review of Henri Mineur's career would not be complete if we did not mention his patriotism and his taste for things military. In 1940 he volunteered to participate more actively in the war. After his discharge he went immediately to the 'France Combattante' movement, where he continued an effective action. Arrested by the occupiers, he was released after a short time which was even considered too short by the French courts to which he was asked to justify his actions shortly after the country was liberated. His conduct was acknowledged as irrefutable by the awarding of the Resistance Medal with a wonderful citation. He then committed himself again until the end of the war.
In fact Mineur's rapid release after being arrested by the Gestapo was because the German astronomer Karl-Otto Kiepenheuer was informed of his arrest by Gabrielle Mineur (who was already separated from her husband by this time) and Kiepenheuer was able to arrange for him to be freed immediately.

Mineur had five years of bad health with heart and liver problems before his death at the early age of 55. An interview given by his wife Gabrielle Mineur in 1986 paints a rather different picture of Henri Mineur's personality than that presented by Daniel Barbier in [2]. It becomes, for example, immediately clear why Mineur suffered from liver problems. Gabrielle Mineur said:-
I was married to a renowned astronomer, Henri Mineur, but had problems, he drank. Tired of the hard life I had endured for ten years, I left. ...

I spoke just now of Henri Mineur, one of the best French astronomers of that time. He had, however, a great personality defect, he drank. ... Of course I was the first to suffer the consequences, imagine for nine years, every night I was beaten. He worked three hours a day, he had an extraordinary facility, he found something and he left all happy. He went to the bistro 'Chez Paul' in the basement of the Place Dauphine, met people who are the poorest, a cobbler, ... "Ah, There is the astronomer ...". He was proud. He had the respect of people to whom he owed nothing. And he remained until two o'clock in the morning. Needless to say in what state he returned. For ten years I tried to save him, I tried to get him out of all that, to be what he should have been: a great personality. I helped him with his work, I had a Bachelor of Science, I was doing mathematics and I started to study astronomy. I made statistical calculations for him concerning the movement of stars and the rotation of the Milky Way. But I felt that my capabilities were inadequate and I was being assigned the role of a calculator. It was not enough. The CNRS was an institute for studying astrophysics. In fact, he had very sound views on the future. But what I couldn't do was to have him appointed Director of the Institute, while I was working there. In addition, as he hated any place other than Paris, he never went to Forcalquier where he was expected to build an observatory. It was Ferenczi and Barbier, the latter a personal friend of Mineur, who took care of the Observatoire de Haute Provence. I have great respect for Barbier who has been an excellent co-worker, who tried to put Mineur on the right track, and who wrote really moving things about him.
Finally, we note that Mineur was twice honoured by the award of prizes from the Académie des Sciences.

References (show)

  1. J R Levy, Biography in Dictionary of Scientific Biography (New York 1970-1990). See THIS LINK.
  2. D Barbier, Henri Mineur (French), Annales d'astrophysique 17 (4) (1954), 239-242.
  3. D Barbier, Obituary Notices: Henri Mineur, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 115 (2) (1955), 129.
  4. A H Copeland, Review : Henri Mineur, Technique de la Méthode des Moindres Carrés by Henri Mineur, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 44 (11) (1938), 766.
  5. J Dufay, Henri Mineur, Astronomie 70 (1956), 235-238.
  6. S Dumont, Henri Mineur, 7 March 1899, Lille-7 May 1954, Paris, in F Combes, G A Mamon and V Charmandaris (eds.), Proceedings of the IAP Meeting held at Institut d'Astrophysique de Paris, 9-13 July 1999 (Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco, 2000), xxi-xxii.
  7. Interview with Gabrielle Mineur in Nice on 10 July 1986, History of the CNRS. http://www.histcnrs.fr/Mineur.html
  8. J Lévy, Henri Paul Mineur, in The Biographical Encyclopedia of Astronomers (Springer, 2007).
  9. W J Luyten, Review: L'Univers en Expansion by Henri Mineur, J. Phys. Chem. 37 (8) (1933), 1086.
  10. H P Robertson, Review: L'Univers en Expansion by Henri Mineur, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 41 (9) (1935), 611.

Additional Resources (show)

Honours (show)

Honours awarded to Henri Mineur

  1. Lunar features Crater Mineur

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update November 2010