Viggo Brun
Quick Info
Lier, Hordaland County, Norway
Drobak, Akershus County, Norway
Biography
Viggo Brun's father was Soren Markus Brun (1838-1893), an artillery captain, and his mother was Lorentze Thaulow Petersen (1842-1890). Now, from the dates we have just given we can see that Viggo's parents died when he was young. In fact his mother died when he was four and his father died on 4 March 1893 when he was seven. However, Viggo was the youngest of his parents' ten children and he had older sisters who brought him up. He entered the University of Oslo in 1903 where he studied mathematics and natural sciences. The course he took was to qualify him to become a school teacher and it was a broad course requiring him to study a wide range of topics. It did not allow time for much in the way of specialised knowledge. Many bright pupils in Brun's position would have read mathematics books to take them into deeper studies than those being presented in their courses. Brun's approach was, however, different and he tried to develop his own mathematical ideas without having the support of teachers or advanced texts and, as a consequence, he produced some rather original ideas while still an undergraduate.In 1910 Brun went to Göttingen University in Germany, the leading mathematics centre in the world at this time, and while he was there he began to work on what were some of the most difficult problems in number theory. We should note that Brun received no financial support for his visit to Göttingen and he funded the visit entirely from his own funds. The number theorist Edmund Landau had been appointed to a professorship at Göttingen a year before Brun arrived and Hilbert and Klein were also on the staff. There is no evidence that Brun interacted in any meaningful way with any of these, but he must have benefited from listening to Edmund Landau. Returning to Norway, Brun did receive a research grant to support his work but at this stage he had no job. The outbreak of World War I in 1914 saw Norway adopt a position of neutrality. This, however, proved difficult to maintain and the country was under pressure from both sides. Brun served for a number of years in the Norwegian armed forces.
He had attacked two of the most famous number theory problems, namely Goldbach's conjecture and the twin prime conjecture. Goldbach's conjecture is that every even natural number greater than 2 can be expressed as the sum of two primes. For example, 4 = 2 + 2, 6 = 3 + 3, 8 = 3 + 5, 10 = 5 + 5, ... Note that, in general, even numbers will be expressible as the sum of two primes in more than one way, for example 10 = 5 + 5 = 3 + 7. The twin prime conjecture is that there are infinitely many prime pairs $n, n + 2$. For example, 3, 5; 5, 7; 11, 13; 17, 19; 29, 31; ... Brun's first results were given in Über das Goldbachsche Gesetz und die Anzahl der Primzahlpaare Ⓣ (1915). In this paper he began to develop the sieve methods which would lead him to some very important results. These sieve methods were refinements, based on the inclusion-exclusion principle, of the sieve of Eratosthenes. They are essentially elementary in nature and few believed that they would lead to significant results. However, the ideas that Brun introduced in this paper, further developed by him and later by others, would lead to a revolution in number theory. In 1919 Brun published a remarkable result when he proved that the sum of the reciprocals of twin primes is finite, that is
$\large\frac{1}{3}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{7}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{11}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{13}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{17}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{19}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{29}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{31}\normalsize + ...$
is finite. He proved this in the paper La série $\large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{7}\normalsize +\large\frac{1}{11}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{13}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{17}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{19}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{29}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{31}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{41}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{43}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{59}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{61}\normalsize + . . .$où les dénominateurs sont "nombres premiers jumeaux" est convergent ou finie Ⓣ (1919) which he published in the Bulletin des Sciences Mathématiques. The proof uses what today is called 'Brun's sieve'. Note that this result is in sharp contrast with the theorem that the sum of the reciprocals of the primes is infinite, first proved by Leonhard Euler in 1737. Now the first question one would naturally ask is "What is the approximate value of the sum of the reciprocals of twin primes"? Unfortunately there is no accepted standard for exactly what series is being summed. The most common definition of 'Brun's constant' is:
$B$ = $\large\frac{1}{3}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{7}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{11}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{13}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{17}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{19}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{29}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{31}\normalsize + ...$
and the best estimate for $B$, produced in 2002, is 1.902160583104.
However, as we can see from the title of Brun's paper, he took a slightly different start to his series
$\large\frac{1}{7}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{11}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{13}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{17}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{19}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{29}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{31}\normalsize + ...$
while others take
$\large\frac{1}{3}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{7}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{11}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{13}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{17}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{19}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{29}\normalsize + \large\frac{1}{31}\normalsize + ...$
omitting one $\large\frac{1}{5}\normalsize$ since 5 appears in two prime pairs. Of course, the sums of these variants are easily related to $B$. Note that it is still an open question whether $B$ is rational or irrational. It is known, however, that if $B$ were proved irrational it would follow that there are infinitely many twin primes. If $B$ were proved rational it would have no bearing on whether there were infinitely many twin primes. Isn't a study of the primes a most fascinating topic!
In 1920 Brun published Le crible de Eratosthène et le théorème de Goldbach Ⓣ in which he used his sieve methods to prove weaker forms of both the Goldbach conjecture and the twin prime conjecture. In this paper he proved (i) there exist infinitely many integers $n$ such that both $n$ and $n + 2$ have at most nine prime factors; and (ii) every sufficiently large even integer $N$ is the sum of two numbers each having at most nine prime factors. Later mathematicians have strengthened these results, using methods based on those first developed by Brun, but the two conjectures are still open.
Let us return to Brun's career. He was appointed as an assistant in applied mathematics in Oslo in 1921. Two years later, he was appointed as a professor at the Technical University of Trondheim. He married Laura Elise Michelsen (1902-2004) in 1940. Laura, who was born in Frogn, Akershus, Norway, to parents Hjalmar Fredrik Bernhard Michelsen and Eva Gloersen, ran a dressmaking school in Oslo. We note that her home town of Frogn was adjacent to Drobak where Brun's father had bought an old house. Viggo and his wife Laura [3]:-
... lived in an ancient wooden house in Drobak, which had been built in 1770 and which his father had bought in 1888. In recent years he and his wife were active in helping to preserve those old houses in Drobak. He loved to go for walks in the forest where he would collect curious pieces of wood or roots from which he produced nice handiwork.In 1946 Brun was appointed to a chair at the University of Oslo which he occupied for nine years until he retired in 1955 at the age of seventy.
Brun published two books after he retired, namely The Art of Calculating in Old Norway until the Time of Abel (Norwegian) (1962) and All is Number, a History of Mathematics from Antiquity to the Renaissance (Norwegian) (1964). Øystein Ore writes [1]:-
Viggo Brun has in recent years written two books on the history of mathematics, one dealing with the early history in Norway, the other with the general story of the subject. Both are on a very elementary level, but with many interesting observations by the author.Brun explains in his Preface that, before Niels Abel, Norwegian mathematics:-
... was in most cases an art of calculating rather than mathematics. No more than four of the scholars I mention could lay claim to the title of mathematician.These four are Fredrich Christian Holberg Arentz (1736-1825), Diderich Christian Fester (1732-1811), Jens Kraft (1720-1756) and Caspar Wessel (1745-1818).
Christoph J Scriba, writes in a review that:-
... the author gives a summary of the knowledge in elementary mathematics in old Norway and Iceland. Apart from archaeological finds bearing geometric designs, the oldest sources revealing knowledge in the art of calculating are contained in the Gulating Law, the Frostating Law and the Kongespeilet [The royal mirror, c. 1260], from the 12th and 13th centuries. Hauk Erlendsson, who lived in Norway and Iceland around 1300, composed an "Algorismus" mainly based on that of Sacrobosco. The Icelandic arithmetic "Rymbegla" is briefly discussed. There is also an account of the teaching of arithmetic in schools, the study of Norwegian students abroad in the Middle Ages and later on, and the establishment of high and technical schools in Denmark and Norway in the 17th and 18th centuries.Christoph J Scriba also reviewed Brun's All is Number, writing:-
This paperback in the Norwegian language contains the substance of lectures on the history of mathematics which have been given at the University of Oslo. A summary of pre-historic, Egyptian, Babylonian, Hindu and Arabic mathematics fills the first 80 pages, while on the next 100 pages the life and work of about two dozen Greek mathematicians is described. Of these, the great Archimedes receives the fullest treatment (34 pages) - the same number of pages in which the author deals with medieval and Renaissance mathematics in Europe, from Boethius to Cardano and Ferrari. The author has resisted the temptation to crowd too many facts into the limited space. His presentation of mathematical details is intermingled with information of a more general nature concerning mathematics and mathematicians of the times under discussion. Some items treated by him are not contained in the standard books: The Norwegian "Kongespeilet", perhaps composed by Archbishop Einar Gunnarsson, who may have been in personal contact with Sacrobosco at Paris; the "Algorismus" of Hauk Erlendsson [early 14th century], which is strongly influenced by Sacrobosco, too; and the Icelandic arithmetic "Rymbegla" [12th -14th centuries?].In addition to these books on the history of mathematics, Brun wrote many papers on the subject. For example, he wrote the following in Norwegian: Quadrature of the circle (1941); The study of the prime numbers from antiquity to our time (1942); Wallis's and Brouncker's formulas for π (1951); Niels Henrik Abel (1953); The manuscript of Abel's Paris treatise found (1953); (with Borge Jessen) A letter by Niels Henrick Abel from his youth (1958). He also published biographies of Carl Stormer (1957), Caspar Wessel (1959), Sophus Lie (1967), and Axel Thue (1977). Another topic that interested Brun was the theory of music. In Music and ternary continued fractions (1950) he discussed the division of the octave into equally tempered intervals. The paper Music and Euclidean algorithms (Norwegian) (1961) looks at four different problems from the theory of music. One might imagine that Brun was musical but [3]:-
Brun himself called it an irony of fate that he, who was very unmusical, should write about music. Though not musically gifted, Viggo Brun had a strong sense for harmony and geometric symmetry. He gave some lectures about mathematics and aesthetics ...Christoph Scriba met Brun in 1955 at a conference on the history of mathematics at the Oberwolfach mathematics research centre in the Black Forest, Germany. Scriba says of Brun [3]:-
His wide interests and his humanistic outlook, combined with his modesty, kindness, and totally un-professorial habits made the strongest impression upon me. ... During his long and fruitful life, he also engaged in politics and worked for peace ...Many honours were given to Brun for his outstanding contributions. He was awarded the Fridtjof Nansen Award for Excellence in 1939. This award, named after the Norwegian explorer, scientist, and diplomat Fridtjof Nansen, had been awarded since 1903 and the previous winner, in 1938, had been Thoralf Albert Skolem. In 1946 Brun was awarded the Norwegian Institute of Technology Founder's Prize, and in 1958 he received the Gunnerus medal of the Royal Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters. This medal is named after Johan Ernst Gunnerus, the founder of the Royal Norwegian Academy. Brun also received an honorary doctorate from the University of Hamburg in 1966. He was elected a member of the scientific societies or academies of Oslo, Trondheim, Uppsala, and the Finnish Academy of Sciences.
References (show)
- O Ore, Review: The Art of Calculating in Old Norway until the Time of Abel, by Viggo Brun; and All is Number, a History of Mathematics from Antiquity to the Renaissance, by Viggo Brun, Amer. Math. Monthly 75 (1) (1968), 100.
- K Ramachandra, Viggo Brun (13.10.1885 to 15.8.1978), Math. Student 49 (1) (1981), 87-95.
- C J Scriba, Viggo Brun in memoriam (1885-1978), Historia Mathematica 7 (1) (1980) 1-6.
- C J Scriba, Zur Erinnerung an Viggo Brun, Mitt. Math. Ges. Hamburg 11 (3) (1985), 271-290.
- S Selberg, Viggo Brun in memoriam (Norwegian), Normat No. 1 (1979), 3-9, 48.
- S Selberg, Viggo Brun (Norwegian), Norske Vid. Selsk. Forh. (Trondheim) (1979), 57-61.
- R Taton, Viggo Brun (1885-1978) (French), Rev. Histoire Sci. Appl. 33 (3) (1980), 253-254.
- H Waadeland, Viggo Brun: 'La difference entre le nombre de nombres premiers des formes 4h + 3 et 4h + 1, exprimés par une formule exacte', m.fl. (Norwegian), Skr. K. Nor. Vidensk. Selsk. (4) (2011), 113-120.
Additional Resources (show)
Other websites about Viggo Brun:
Cross-references (show)
Written by
J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update March 2014
Last Update March 2014