Aubrey William Ingleton


Quick Info

Born
14 August 1920
Chester, Cheshire, England
Died
1 June 2000
Headington, Oxford, England

Summary
Aubrey Ingleton spent most of his career at Birkbeck College London and Oxford University where he had a reputation as an outstanding tutor. He published on a wide area of mathematical topics and made particularly important contributions to matroid theory.

Biography

Aubrey Ingleton was the son of William Ingleton (1890-1967) and Jessie Gertrude Owen (1894-1946). William Ingleton was born in Islington, London, on 22 August 1890, the eldest of his parents' four children. At the time of the 1911 Census he was living with his parents in Islington and his occupation is given as silversmith. He married Jessie Gertrude Owen in All Saints Church, Hoole, Cheshire, England on 3 November 1917. Jessie Owen had been born on 21 November 1894 in Newton, Cheshire, the daughter of a railway clerk. In the 1911 Census her occupation is given as bookkeeper.

William and Jessie Ingleton had two children, Aubrey William Ingleton, the subject of this biography born in 1920, and Geoffrey Douglas Ingleton (1922-1990), born in Chester on 11 January 1922. Geoffrey Douglas Ingleton was baptised in All Saints Church, Hoole, Chester on 12 September 1920. The family were, at that time, living at 28 Vicarage Road, Hoole, Chester and William Ingleton's occupation is listed as accountant. The 1921 Census records the Ingleton family living at 39 City Road, Chester. William Ingleton is a Civilian Acting Paymaster in the Royal Army Pay Corps working in the Army Pay Office, Western Command, Stanley Place, Chester. Geoffrey Ingleton became a civil servant in the Air Ministry. In 1963 he was Senior Base Training Captain, Vanguard Aircraft, British European Airways Corporation and received the Queen's Commendation for Valuable Service in the Air.

Aubrey Ingleton was educated at Tollington Preparatory School, Muswell Hill, London and continued his education at Tollington School, Muswell Hill. The Tollington Boys School had been founded in 1901 as an independent school but in 1919 had been bought by Middlesex Education Committee which bought the High School at the same time. It created Tollington Preparatory School and Tollington Boys School. After an outstanding school career, Ingleton graduated in 1937 and after being extraordinarily successful in the Civil Service entrance examination entered the Civil Service at the age of 16. The local paper contained the following announcement:-
Congratulations to 16-year-old Aubrey William Ingleton, prefect at Tollington School Muswell Hill, who has been placed first out of 7,371 candidates in the recent Civil Service examination, general clerical class. Aubrey has had a brilliant school career and is exceptionally good at Mathematics. When he took the examination to enter Tollington from Tollington Preparatory School he gained 100 per cent for his arithmetic paper.
On 27 May 1937, after an open competition, Aubrey Ingleton was appointed as a tax officer in the Inland Revenue Department. In the 1939 England and Wales Register, he is listed as living at 83 Manor Drive, Friern Barnet, Middlesex with his parents and younger brother. On 29 September 1939 he became an Audit Assistant in the Ministry of Heath. By this time World War II had started: Germany invaded Poland on 1 September 1939 and two days later Great Britain and France declared war on Germany. It is, of course, impossible to know whether Ingleton would have become a mathematician if his career in the Civil Service had not been interrupted by the war. What is certainly beyond dispute is that the course of his career changed dramatically during the war years.

In 1941 Ingleton was seconded into the Fleet Air Arm, the naval aviation component of the United Kingdom's Royal Navy. There he undertook research into radar. On 6 November 1944 he was appointed Temporary Acting Sub-Lieutenant in the Royal Navy. It was during this time when he was undertaking war work, in particular research into radar, that Ingleton decided that he did not want to continue with a Civil Service career but wanted a career in mathematics. When World War II ended in 1945 and Ingleton was released from his duties in the Royal Navy he returned to his position at the Ministry of Heath but was already making plans to study advanced mathematics.

In 1946 he enrolled in the Northern Polytechnic which had opened in Holloway, North London in 1896. At this time polytechnics could not award degrees but they taught courses which allowed students to take external University of London degree examinations. Ingleton took the external University of London examinations in 1949 and was awarded a B.Sc. degree with First Class Honours in Mathematics. He was awarded the Lubbock Prize, a prestigious academic award given by the University of London to the student with the best First Class honours degree in Mathematics. It was an extraordinary achievement for an external student to win this prize. But this was not the only prize that Ingleton was awarded, for he also received the Sherbrooke Prize for having the best performance in the mathematics finals.

In 1949, after completing his B.Sc. degree, Ingleton enrolled at King's College London to study for Ph.D. He was assigned Anthony Francis Ruston (1920-2005) as his thesis advisor. Let us note that Ruston, who was the same age as Ingleton, was a student of Frank Smithies and was appointed to King's College in 1949. Ruston had submitted the 59-page paper Direct products of Banach spaces and linear functional equations to the London Mathematical Society on 18 November 1948 in which he gives the following acknowledgements:-
I am indebted to Dr F Smithies for suggesting this problem to me, and for assistance in the preparation of this paper. I also wish to thank Mr N A Routledge for his assistance in checking the manuscript, and Mr A W Ingleton for helpful advice.
On this paper Ruston gives his address as Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge, where he was a research student, and he must have written it when Ingleton was enrolled in the Northern Polytechnic so how they were in contact at this time is a puzzle we would like to solve.

Anthony D Barnard gives an interesting account of the Mathematics Department at King's College London at this time [11]:-
George Temple had resumed as Head of the Mathematics Department after the war; other members of the Department with whom Ingleton interacted included Jack Semple, Richard Rado and Bernard Scott. Scott, who was a major source of exchange of ideas between colleagues, shared a room with Ruston. The King's Mathematics Department was known throughout the College and the University, not only for its academic excellence, but also for its informal and friendly atmosphere. There was one, short, departmental meeting a year, after the end of the summer term, when people would volunteer for the courses to be given the next year. The emphasis was very much on how to provide each member of staff with as much time as possible for research. There was also a strong tradition that anyone who had given a ten o'clock lecture (or who was to give one at eleven) would go down to the refectory to have coffee with the undergraduates.
Certainly Ingleton made very rapid progress with his research, for having enrolled at King's College in 1949 he submitted the paper The Hahn-Banach theorem for non-Archimedean valued fields to the Cambridge Philosophical Society on 4 January 1951. The paper begins with the following Introduction [16]:-
The Hahn-Banach theorem on the extension of linear functionals holds in real and complex Banach spaces, but it is well known that it is not in general true in a normed linear space over a field with a non-Archimedean valuation. Sufficient conditions for its truth in such a space have been given, however, by A F Monna and by I S Cohen. In the present paper, we show that a necessary condition for the property is that the space be totally non-Archimedean in the sense of Monna, and establish a necessary and sufficient condition on the field for the theorem to hold in every totally non-Archimedean space over the field. This result is obtained as a special case of a more general theorem concerning linear operators, which is analogous to a theorem of Nachbin (A theorem of the Hahn-Banach type for linear transformations (1950)) concerning operators in real Banach spaces.
In the review [12] of this paper I S Cohen writes:-
Let K be a field with a non-trivial non-Archimedean valuation, E a linear space over K having a real-valued norm with customary properties. It is proved that a necessary condition for the Hahn-Banach theorem to hold for linear functionals on subspaces of E is that E be non-Archimedean, that is, satisfy the strong triangle inequality: x+ymax(x,y|x + y| ≤ max(|x|,|y|. For a given K it is shown that in order for the Hahn-Banach theorem to hold in every non-Archimedean space over K, it is necessary and sufficient that the intersection of any totally ordered collection of spheres in K be non-empty. This condition on K is equivalent to maximal completeness.
This paper was essentially Ingleton's Ph.D. thesis, submitted in 1951, and he was awarded the degree by the University of London in 1952.

In 1951 he was appointed to a lectureship at Birkbeck College London where Cyril Offord was head of the Mathematics Department. Offord appointed Hugh Dowker as a Reader in 1950, and Ingleton as an Assistant Lecturer in 1951. Anthony D Barnard writes [11]:-
Ingleton was Offord's second appointment. Assistant lecturers at small UK institutions with well-connected heads-of-department were generally recruited through the grapevine, and Offord will have heard about Ingleton, probably from Ruston. As an analyst, Offord will have particularly appreciated a geometer (which the Department lacked) whose first research topic had been a generalised Hahn-Banach theorem. The Department was friendly and very pleasant to work in; though (except for the analysts, who organised a seminar) it was too small and heterogeneous to generate much productive interaction. However, the proximity of King's and University College largely compensated for this. The geometry in the London Honours degree, which (at least initially) took up most of Ingleton's teaching time, was predominantly the projective theory of quadrics, bits about twisted cubics and some classical differential geometry.
In 1952 Ingleton married Joan L Bremner, daughter of Archibald Bremner (1891-1969) and Lilian W Bradshaw (1894-1969). Joan Bremner was born in Woolwich, Kent in 1925. Aubrey and Joan Ingleton had a daughter Annette who was born in 1957.

Ingleton had broad interests in mathematics and would engage in discussions with colleagues who were experts in widely different areas. Remarkably he would often make substantial contributions after these discussions. Let us give some examples. He chatted with Clive Kilmister who, at that time, was writing a book on special relativity. Following these conversations, Ingleton published The Lorentz transformation in Nature in 1953. After conversations with his Birkbeck colleagues Richard Cooke and Paul Vermes, Ingleton published The rank of circulant matrices in the Journal of the London Mathematical Society in 1956. A circulant matrix is a square matrix in which all rows are composed of the same elements and each row is rotated one element to the right relative to the preceding row. A circulant matrix is called rr-recurrent if the sequence defining it has a repeating pattern for some rr that is a proper divisor of nn. Ingleton explains the contents of the paper in his introduction:-
In this paper we are mainly interested in matrices of 0's and l's. The condition of being circulant imposes a restriction on the possible values for the rank of such a matrix and we can, in particular, define an integer ρ(n)\rho(n) as the least possible rank of a non-recurrent circulant matrix of 0's and 1's of a given order n. We obtain the value of ρ(n)\rho(n) for a certain class of values of n, but the results only yield upper and lower bounds for ρ(n)\rho(n) in general. Further progress is possible, but the existence of a simple explicit expression for ρ(n)\rho(n) valid for all n seems doubtful. The corresponding problem for matrices with arbitrary rational coefficients is, however, much more tractable and a complete solution is given.
We note that circulant matrices with entries 0's and l's were involved in research that Paul Vermes was undertaking.

Bernard Scott invited Ingleton to join him and his research student in reading Friedrich Hirzebruch's book on new topological methods in algebraic geometry. This led to Ingleton writing several papers on tangent flag bundles. Ingleton's colleague Richard Rado wrote Note on independent functions and this led to Ingleton becoming interested in matroid theory. His first paper on matroids was in 1959 but perhaps his most significant was Representation of matroids. This paper, published in 1971, was based on the lecture Ingleton delivered to the conference 'Combinatorial Mathematics and its Applications' held in Oxford in 1969. Dominic Welsh begins his review of this paper as follows [18]:-
This is a very valuable and interesting paper which surveys the representability problem for matroids and contains several new constructions and results.
One of the important new results proved by Ingleton in this paper is now known as Ingleton's inequality and, in addition to its importance on matroid theory also has been shown to have important consequences in information theory and network coding.

Between these two papers on matroid theory that we have just mentioned Ingleton made several moves. In 1961 he was appointed as Mathematics Tutor at New College, Oxford University. Barnard writes [11]:-
Influential in this move was E C Titchmarsh, who was then Savilian Professor of Geometry at Oxford (a chair associated with New College), and who had known Ingleton from his lectures at University College London and thought very highly of him.
In 1966 he was appointed to the Chair of Mathematics at Cardiff University. He wanted to make changes to the way that mathematics at Cardiff operated but found resistance to his ideas from the Cardiff staff. Knowing that he was unhappy at Cardiff, Balliol College Oxford approached him in 1967 with the offer of a position as Pure Mathematics Tutor in the College and a Fellowship. He held these positions until he retired in 1985.

Paul Seymour was an undergraduate at Oxford University, obtaining a B.A. in 1971. He then began postgraduate studies preparing his M.Sc. dissertation On the two-colouring of hypergraphs supervised by Ingleton. Seymour continued to undertake research for a Ph.D. advised by Ingleton and was awarded the degree in 1975 for his thesis Matroids, hypergraphs and the max.-flow min.-cut theorem. Seymour continued to undertake research on the topics to which he had been introduced by Ingleton, and has had a profound impact on combinatorics, graph theory and theoretical computer science.

Soon after he retired Ingleton became ill and although he recovered, he gave up mathematical research at this time. Fifteen years later the illness recurred leading to his death at the age of 79.

Let us end by giving quotes about Ingleton's character. Barnard writes [11]:-
He was known to be a man of sound judgement, who was totally open, one who did not court disputes but who was not afraid to speak his mind, though never in such a way as to give offence.
Sir Anthony Kenny, Master of Balliol from 1978 to 1989, gave an address at Ingleton's funeral. he explained that Ingleton:-
... spent few words, but those words he spent were words well spent. You always knew that what he told you was true, and that what he promised you would get done. He had no great taste for college feasts or festivals, and ceased to attend them once he was no longer obliged by duty to do so. However, even as an emeritus fellow, he liked to come regularly into the common room to read the newspapers amid the companionship of the fellows. ... Most of us knew little of his hobbies: of his gift for composing chess problems, for instance, or his learned interest in the local history of Headington, or his encyclopaedic knowledge of vintage railway engines. But his passion for the Hebrides, the invariable scene of his annual holidays, was an open secret. ... I recall Aubrey as a paradigm of the type of devoted tutor and conscientious college officer that has been, throughout the century just ended, the backbone of the Oxford collegiate system.
We should add a comment regarding Ingleton and chess problems. He was interested in problems, not only for conventional chess, but also but variants. For example he created puzzles for Circe Chess, in which captured men return to their "home square" unless it is occupied. The Games and Puzzles Journal and the Variant Chess Newsletter both contain many references to award winning puzzles submitted by Ingleton.

Le us end by quoting from the obituary written by Ingleton's colleague Dominic Welsh:-
... on a personal note, my memory of Aubrey is as a totally reliable, wonderful colleague. We met every week at the Tuesday combinatorics seminar. He was usually quiet, not one to venture wild conjectures or the like, but what he said was almost always correct. Indeed, I lost count of the times that shortly after the seminar, either that evening or the next day, I would get a phone call or precisely written note with a counterexample to some conjecture or problems that had been put forward at the tea conversation after the seminar.


References (show)

  1. Aubrey W Ingleton, 1939 England and Wales Register (2025).
  2. Aubrey William Ingleton, Mathematics Genealogy Project (2025).
    https://mathgenealogy.org/id.php?id=42253
  3. Aubrey William Ingleton, 1921 England Census (2025).
  4. Aubrey William Ingleton, Find a Grave (2025).
    https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/255405866/aubrey-william-ingleton
  5. Aubrey William Ingleton, Cheshire, England, Church of England Baptisms, 1813-1923 (2025).
  6. Aubrey William Ingleton, UK, Navy Lists, 1888-1970 (2025).
  7. Aubrey William Ingleton, The London Gazette (11 June 1937).
  8. Aubrey William Ingleton, The London Gazette (29 September 1939).
  9. Aubrey William Ingleton, The London Gazette (16 May 1941).
  10. Aubrey William Ingleton, The London Gazette (7 February 1942).
  11. A D Barnard, Obituary: Aubrey William Ingleton 1920-2000, Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society 36 (1) (2004), 119-129.
  12. I S Cohen, Review: The Hahn-Banach theorem for non-Archimedean valued fields, by Aubrey W Ingleton, Mathematical Reviews MR0045939 (13,659d).
  13. A W Ingleton, Representation of matroids, in D J A Welsh (ed.), Combinatorial Mathematics and its Applications (Oxford, 1969), 149-167.
  14. A W Ingleton, Conditions for representability and transversality of matroids, in C P Bruter (ed.), Actes du Rencontre Franco-Britannique, Brest, 14-15 May 1970, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 211 (Springer, 1971), 62-66.
  15. A W Ingleton, A geometrical characterization of transversal independence structures, Bulletin of the London Mathematical Society 3 (1971), 47-51.
  16. A W Ingleton, The Hahn-Banach theorem for non-Archimedean valued fields, Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 48 (1) (1952), 41-45.
  17. A Miller, Review: Conditions for representability and transversality of matroids, by Aubrey W Ingleton, Mathematical Reviews MR0337664 (49 #2433).
  18. D J A Welsh, Review: Representation of matroids, by Aubrey W Ingleton, Mathematical Reviews MR0278974 (43 #4700).

Additional Resources (show)


Cross-references (show)


Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update December 2025