Boris Yakovlevich Levin

Quick Info

22 December 1906
Odessa, Russia (now Ukraine)
24 August 1993
Kharkiv, Ukraine

Boris Yakovlevich Levin was a Soviet mathematician who made contributions to function theory.


Boris Yakovlevich Levin's father, Yakov Levin, was a clerk for a Black Sea steamer company. This meant that Yakov was based for long periods in several different Black Sea ports and so, as Boris Yakovlevich was growing up, he lived in many different towns. The sea came to be an important part of the boy's life: he became a strong swimmer with a passion for the sea. Let us note at this point that although we will refer to the subject of this biography as Levin, he was known as B. Ya. to his friends and colleagues. After graduating from the high school in Yeysk, a port on the Sea of Azov, Levin was not able to continue to higher education and had to take a job. He worked at a number of different jobs, in particular as an insurance agent and distributing newspapers in Yeysk. He then moved to Tuapse, situated on the north east shore of the Black Sea, where he learnt to be a welder.

Oil was extracted from the region of the North Caucasus's in the 19th century but only in the 1920s were geological studies carried out in the foothills of the mountains. Drilling began in 1924 and pipelines had to be constructed. Levin worked as a welder on pipeline construction for a while, in particular on the pipeline to the refinery in Grozny, and this earned him the right to a university education. He entered the Department of Physics and Engineering of Rostov University in 1928, in the same year as Nikolai Vladimirovich Efimov. Although four years younger than Levin, Efimov had also had a variety of short-term jobs in construction before beginning his higher education studies. Both Levin and Efimov had the intention of taking a physics degree, but they felt that their knowledge of mathematics was insufficient to benefit from launching straight into physics courses so both decided to take mathematics courses in their first year. They were taught by Dmitry Dmitrievich Morduhai-Boltovskoi (1876-1952) who had been awarded his doctorate from St Petersburg State University in the year Levin was born. Morduhai-Boltovskoi had established a research school in Rostov and both Levin and Efimov were quickly drawn into high level mathematics which they found very exciting.

Levin, despite his decision to take a degree in physics, soon realised that mathematics was the topic that was right for him. Morduhai-Boltovskoi had Levin undertaking research from his second year of study, proposing a problem to him about generalising the functional equation for the Euler G-function. Levin solved the problem and, a few years later, published his solution in the paper Generalization of a theorem of Hölder (Russian) (1934). Levin graduated in 1932 but continued to undertake research at Rostov University advised by Morduhai-Boltovskoi. At this stage he was not working towards a higher degree since the academic degrees of Master of Science and Doctor of Science had been abolished in the USSR in 1918. However, they were reintroduced in 1934 so that Levin was able, at that time, to consider his research as being towards a thesis for a higher degree. He was not a full-time research student, however, for he took a position teaching mathematics at the Technical University of Rostov.
Levin began friendships at this time with two young mathematicians who worked at different universities, friendships which were to prove important in later life. Naum Il'ich Akhiezer, who worked at Kharkov (now Kharkiv) University, was in the same position as Levin, having been unable gain a higher degree since they were abolished. Levin's other friend, Mark Grigorievich Krein, was working at Odessa University in the city where Levin had been born.

With the reintroduction of the higher degree in 1934, Levin decided to submit his thesis for a Candidate's Degree (equivalent to a Ph.D. by today's standards). However, before submitting to the University of Rostov, Levin moved to Odessa in 1935 to take up a position at the University of Marine Engineering. He was already publishing papers and, in addition to the one we mentioned above, he had published The arithmetic properties of holomorphic functions (1933), The intersection of algebraic curves (1934), Entire functions of irregular growth (1936), and The growth of the Sturm-Liouville integral equation (1936). Although we have given these papers English titles, all were written in Russian. He submitted his thesis 0n the growth of an entire function along a ray, and the distribution of its zeros with respect to their arguments to the University of Rostov in 1936 but, although the thesis was submitted for a Candidate's Degree, the university took the highly unusual step of awarding Levin the higher degree of Doctor of Science (equivalent to a D.Sc.).

Mark Grigorievich Krein had been appointed to the staff at Odessa University after being a research student there. He had begun to build a functional analysis research group there which was to become one of the most important centres in the world. Joining the Odessa research team, Levin [16]:-
... spent a lot of time and effort in advising his colleagues who worked on hydrodynamical problems of ships and mechanics of construction. In his later years he would say that teaching and communicating with engineers in a serious technical university is an important experience for a mathematician.

... as he later used to say, experienced its strengthening influence. He became interested in almost periodic functions, quasi-analytic classes and related problems of completeness and approximation, algebraic problems of the theory of entire functions, and Sturm-Liouville operators. These remained the main fields of interest during his life.
When World War II broke out, Levin tried to enlist in the military. However, university professors had to contribute in other ways to the war effort and he was not permitted to enlist. He went to the Institute in Samarkand, Uzbekistan. In June 1941 all staff had to leave Odessa when the university was evacuated to Uzbekistan as the German armies advanced. By the end of August 1941 German armies surrounded the city and the Germans controlled it until April 1944 when it was recaptured. Levin returned to Odessa when the university reopened again but at this stage the functional analysis school at Odessa was closed down. Krein was accused of favouring Jews, and it was claimed that he had too many Jewish students before the War. Krein was put in an impossible position by the university. He had to leave and the whole of the functional analysis school at Odessa was closed down. Vladimir Petrovich Potapov, who had been one of the non-Jewish students in the functional analysis group and had become a Ph.D. student of Levin's in 1939, tried hard to influence the university authorities to reverse their decisions. He wrote:-
The leaders of the university have to correct their mistakes and to revive immediately the famous traditions of the Odessa School of Mathematics. The Faculty of Physics and Mathematics has to become active again, as a really creative centre of scientific and mathematical thought in our city ....
Selim Grigorievich Krein was Mark Grigorievich Krein's younger brother and he studied at Kiev State University advised by Nikolai Nikolaevich Bogolyubov. Selim Krein, like his older brother, worked on functional analysis and, after writing some papers with his older brother and with his advisor, he worked with Levin. They wrote several joint papers: On the convergence of singular integrals (1948), On the strong representation of functions by singular integrals (1948), On certain non-linear questions of the theory of singular integrals (1948), and On a problem posed by I P Natanson (1948). These papers were all written in Russian and the last two also had Boris Korenblum as a joint author.

The difficult situation in Odessa was resolved for Levin in 1949 when he received an invitation from Naum Il'ich Akhiezer to join him at Kharkov University [7]:-
In the Kharkov period, Levin developed the majorant theory, making it possible to explain the Bernstein inequalities from a unified viewpoint, wrote his famous monograph on the distribution of roots of entire functions, created the theory of subharmonic majorants, gave nontrivial estimates for functions polyharmonic in half-spaces, and made a fundamental contribution to the theory of exponential bases.
The famous monograph mentioned in this quote is Distribution of zeros of entire functions (Russian) (1956) which was translated into English as Distribution of zeros of entire functions (1964). R P Boas, Jr writes in a review of the Russian text:-
This is the third book on entire functions to have appeared in the last few years; its objectives and its contents differ considerably from those of the other two [Boas, 'Entire functions' (1954) and Cartwright, 'Integral functions' (1956)], although a certain amount of overlap is inevitable. The first half of the book consists mainly of material that is fairly well covered, or is even covered in more detail, in other books or in journals that will be more accessible to Western readers; the second half consists mainly of material that has not previously appeared in books in any language ... A number of the author's own results, previously announced without proof or only with sketches of proofs, are proved in detail. The book will be a useful reference for much interesting material that is not easily accessible elsewhere.
The authors of [11] and [12] write:-
The remarkable thing about Levin's book is that he does not only treat general fundamentals of the theory of entire functions, the classical results of Hadamard and Lindelöf, but also sets out the most important recent research and gives an account of numerous and often unexpected results in the adjacent fields of classical and functional analysis.
A revised English edition appeared in 1980. Levin explains in this work how he has treated material that has appeared since the first edition:-
Since the appearance of the first edition many papers have been published on the theory of functions of completely regular growth and related topics. However, we do not have the time to expound these new results, which would fill an additional volume. We have tried to make up for this shortcoming by stating new results in a number of places, without proofs, when they are connected with the topics under discussion. We have also added an appendix, 'Further development of the theory of functions of completely regular growth', in which we present a survey of recent results. In addition, we have cited papers in which this material is presented in more detail, with proofs.
Levin taught a wide variety of courses at Kharkov University [16]:-
In addition to undergraduate courses of calculus, theory of functions of a complex variable and functional analysis, he taught advanced courses on entire functions, quasi-analytic classes, almost periodic functions, harmonic analysis and approximation theory, and Banach algebras. The lectures were distinguished by their originality, depth and elegance. Levin used to include his own, yet-unpublished results as well as new original proofs of known theorems. He attracted a very wide audience of students of various levels and also research mathematicians.
In 1956, the year he published the first edition of his famous book, Levin organised a scientific seminar which attracted many participants and trained a whole generation of first class mathematicians. The seminar focused on complex analysis and its applications but was wide ranging and included talks on a many different areas of analysis. As to his other mathematical contributions we have already given an indication above but let us now also quote from [13] and [14]:-
First we must mention the theory of almost periodic functions. In the 40's Levin gave an essentially new construction of Levitan's theory of almost periodic functions and together with M G Krein he studied Harald Bohr's almost periodic functions with bounded spectrum. Of his results on the spectral theory of differential operators we shall mention only the construction, dating from the 50's, of the operator "attached to infinity" of the transformation for the Schrödinger equation, which played an important part in the solution of the inverse problem in the theory of scattering.
In 1969, in addition to his role at the University, Levin took on the role of Head of the Department of the Theory of Functions at the Institute for Low Temperature Physics and Engineering of the Academy of Sciences of Ukraine. However, life in Kharkov was not easy for Levin who found it increasingly hard to undertake his university duties. He was hardly admitted to the university, never put on committees formed to examine Ph.D.s, not even those on complex function theory. According to [1]:-
He became very angry and swore that he would never get involved with the university or any kind of activity which was affiliated with it. So, he came just for the function theory seminar, whose actual leader he was even though the official leader was I V Ostrovskii.
This statement is challenged by some members of the seminar, and in fact Levin continued to teach some courses at Kharkov and in later years Levin and Ostrovskii ran the seminar together.

He was nearly eighty years old before he was allowed to travel abroad so his opportunities to meet his international colleagues was severely limited. He lived, with his wife Liya, in a small ground-floor apartment which was damp and unhealthy. Nevertheless he would invite his colleagues to his home and after long enjoyable mathematical discussions they would be joined by Liya for supper [16]:-
After traditional strong tea which Levin always made himself, there was the time for discussing politics and politicians, for storytelling and poetry, in which Levin was the expert and connoisseur.
Levin's character is described in [5] and [6]:-
Levin enjoyed a long life, full of mathematical quest and discovery. He was ever a man of the highest principles, which he defended openly, in spite of all the blows that fate dealt him. A brilliant mathematician, wonderful lecturer, a most interesting conversationalist, a witty and resourceful opponent, a great connoisseur and judge of literature, a man who would offer help at times of need, ever considerate and benevolent to those around him, Levin emitted some kind of special energy which helped to bring the best out of those in his company, and which attracted to him the most varied of people, sometimes people who had no connection at all with the exact sciences.

References (show)

  1. H Dym, Topics in Interpolation Theory (Springer, New York, 1997).
  2. N I Akhiezer and N V Efimov, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on the fiftieth anniversary of his birth) (Russian), Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 12 2(74) (1957), 237-242.
  3. N I Akhiezer, N V Efimov, M G Krein, M A Lavrent'ev, V A Marchenko, I V Ostrovskii and B V Shabat, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his seventieth birthday) (Russian), Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 32 (5) (1977), 211-213.
  4. N I Akhiezer, N V Efimov, M G Krein, M A Lavrent'ev, V A Marchenko, I V Ostrovskii and B V Shabat, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his seventieth birthday), Russian Math. Surveys 32 (5) (1977), 181-184.
  5. V S Azarin, A A Goldberg, E A Gorin, V A Marchenko, I V Ostrovskii, A V Pogorelov, L.I. Ronkin, M L Sodin, V A Tkachenko, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (obituary) (Russian), Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 49 (1) (1994), 201-202.
  6. V S Azarin, A A Goldberg, E A Gorin, V A Marchenko, I V Ostrovskii, A V Pogorelov, L.I. Ronkin, M L Sodin, V A Tkachenko, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (obituary), Russian Math. Surveys 49 (1) (1994), 219-221.
  7. Boris Yakovlevich Levin, Functional Analysis and its Applications 40 (4) (2006), 247-248.
  8. Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on the centenary of his birth) (Russian), Zh. Mat. Fiz. Anal. Geom. 3 (1) (2007), 3.
  9. Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on the centenary of his birth) (Russian), Funktsional. Anal. i Prilozhen. 40 (4) (2006), 1-2.
  10. Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on the centenary of his birth), Funct. Anal. Appl. 40 (4) (2006), 247-248.
  11. N V Efimov, M G Krein and I V Ostrovskii, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his sixtieth birthday) (Russian), Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 23 (5) (1968), 187-191.
  12. N V Efimov, M G Krein and I V Ostrovskii, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his sixtieth birthday), Russian Math. Surveys 23 (5) (1968), 141-145.
  13. I M Gel'fand, M G Krein, V A Marchenko, N K Nikol'skii and I V Ostrovskii, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his eightieth birthday) (Russian), Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 42 (4) (1987), 207-210.
  14. I M Gel'fand, M G Krein, V A Marchenko, N K Nikol'skii and I V Ostrovskii, Boris Yakovlevich Levin (on his eightieth birthday), Russian Math. Surveys 42 (1987), 175-178.
  15. In memory of Boris Yakovlevich Levin (1906-1993) (Russian), Mat. Fiz. Anal. Geom. 1 (2) (1994), 358-359.
  16. Y Lyubarskii, M Sodin and V Tkachenko, Preface, in B Ya Levin, Lectures on Entire Functions (American Mathematical Society, Providence, R.I., 1996), xi-xiv.

Additional Resources (show)

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update May 2013