Mario Pieri

Quick Info

22 June 1860
Lucca, Tuscany (now Italy)
1 March 1913
S Andrea di Compito (near Lucca), Tuscany, Italy

Mario Pieri was an Italian mathematician who worked in projective geometry and the foundations of geometry.


Mario Pieri's parents were Pellegrino Pieri and Erminia Luporini. Pellegrino, who was born in Vellano east of Lucca, was a lawyer but he was also a highly respected scholar who had written historical works. He had been honoured for his achievements with election to the Royal Lucca Academy of Sciences, Letters and Arts. Pellegrino and Erminia Pieri had eight children: Teresa (born 1853), Silvio Dante (born 1856), Mario (the subject of this biography), Gemma (born 1863), Ferruccio Fabio (born 1864), Paolina Livia (born 1865), Felice Ettore Pacifico Giovanni (born 1866) and Virginia (born 1867). Mario attended elementary school in Lucca from 1866 to 1872 and there learnt to play the piano. In fact his music teacher, Gaetano Luporini, had a big influence on the young boy and for a long time he was unsure whether he should pursue a career in music or in mathematics. After elementary school, he spent four years at the Technical School in Lucca.

In 1876 Mario entered the Royal Technical Institute in Bologna. His elder brother Silvio was undertaking postgraduate work at the University of Bologna on literature and philology at this time and Mario lived with his brother who took on the role of being his guardian and mentor. Mario studied Italian, French, German, social studies and mathematics throughout his four-year course, taking courses in physics, chemistry and natural history in his final two years. His physics teacher was Augusto Righi, a young man who went on to have a fine research career in physics, and Righi quickly saw the great potential in his student Mario. His performance improved steadily during these four years so that he moved from being a middle-ranked student to the top of his class by the time he graduated in 1880.

Mario's family wanted him to study at the Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa but their finances did not stretch to sending him there at that time. A decision was taken that he would spend one year at the University of Bologna so he could continue to live with Silvio (who had one more year of study there). He entered the University of Bologna in 1880, having had the fees waived, taking the courses on 'Projective geometry' and 'Design for projective geometry' with Pietro Boschi. He also took the 'Algebra and analytic geometry' course given by Cesare Arzelà, and courses on physics, chemistry and mineralogy. His talents for mathematics were quickly spotted by Salvatore Pincherle, who took up the chair of mathematics at Bologna in 1881, when he examined Pieri in June of that year. As his family had hoped, Pieri was awarded a scholarship to study at the Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa and he began his studies there in November 1881. At Pisa, Pieri had some distinguish mathematicians as his lecturers both at the Scuola Normale Superiore and at the University of Pisa (he attended courses at both institutions). He was taught 'Calculus' in 1881-82 by Ulisse Dini who also taught him 'Higher analysis' in the following year. Enrico Betti taught him 'Mechanics' in 1882-83, and 'Mathematical physics' and 'Celestial mechanics' in the following year. Luigi Bianchi taught him 'Algebraic functions' in 1882-83 and 'Differential geometry' in 1883-84. Pieri's thesis, On the Singularities of the Jacobian of Four, of Three, of Two Surfaces, which supervised by Bianchi, was submitted to the University of Pisa in 1884. His graduation at the University of Pisa took place on 28 June 1884; he received a commendation in mathematics. He wrote the thesis, Studies in Differential Geometry, also supervised by Bianchi, which he submitted to the Scuola Normale Superiore in Pisa in September 1884.

After graduating, he began teaching at a secondary school in Livorno, then returned to Pisa in October 1885 when, with a recommendation from Dini, he was appointed to the Technical School there. He also gave a series of lectures on polyhedra at the Scuola Normale Superiore. After teaching for a year in Pisa, Pieri won the competition for a professorship at the Royal Military Academy in Turin where he became professor of projective and descriptive geometry in November 1886. His father had died in 1882 and his brother Silvio was teaching in secondary schools, so Pieri had his mother and sister Virginia come to live with him in Turin. In 1888 he also was appointed an assistant to the chair of projective geometry at the University of Turin [3]:-
By then Pieri had published seven research papers. Soon, D'Ovidio presented Pieri's 1889 paper 'On Triple Tangents of Certain Surfaces of Sixth Order' to the Royal Academy of Sciences of Turin, the first of fourteen that Pieri would publish in its journals. By [1890] he had published about ten works, including an edited translation of G K C von Staudt's 1847 'Geometrie der Lage' .
In 1891 Pieri received his 'libero docente', which is similar to the habilitation and gives the right to lecture in universities, from the University of Turin. This was awarded in the light of his outstanding research papers published over the preceding few years as well as his lecture notes Geometria proiettiva: Lezioni per gli allievi nella Reale Accademia Militare di Torino, which "students found very beneficial". He taught projective geometry courses there for several years. However, he continued to seek university appointments. In 1891 he entered the competition for the chair of analytic and projective geometry at the University of Rome which was won by Guido Castelnuovo (Pieri came third equal). Two years later he entered the competition for the chair of projective geometry at the University of Naples (Domenico Montesano won with Pieri fourth equal), and the competition for the chair of projective and descriptive geometry at the University of Turin (Luigi Berzolari won with Pieri second equal).

The chair at Bologna was left vacant when Montesano left to take up the chair at Naples. Pincherle invited Pieri to apply writing (see [3]):-
I knew already the outcome, rather flattering to you, of the competitions at Naples and Turin, and would be quite happy if, having had you as student in Bologna, it should be possible to have you as colleague.
Pincherle hoped that he could appoint Pieri without holding a competition and, on 18 November 1893, Augusto Righi contacted Pieri with the news that the Faculty at Bologna had approved his appointment. He congratulated Pieri. However, Federigo Enriques hoped he might still have a chance to be appointed and approached Volterra and others to press his claims. It appeared that it was a formality that the minister of education took the advice of the Faculty of Bologna and would confirm Pieri's appointment but the government became embroiled in a scandal and the minister of education resigned. The new minister of education did not approve Pieri's appointment, telling the Faculty at Bologna that they had to hold a competition and make a temporary appointment while this was taking place. Enriques was appointed to the temporary post in January 1894. Pieri remained in Turin and concentrated on research, becoming less interested in finding a more prestigious post. The competition for the permanent Bologna post did not take place until October 1896; Enriques was appointed with Pieri coming a close second.

In 1900 Pieri left Turin to take up an appointment at the University of Catania in eastern Sicily, after winning the competition for a chair. In Catania he taught projective geometry and descriptive geometry but also took on the teaching of projective geometry to give him a better salary. He married Angiolina Anastasio Janelli on 27 July 1901. Angiolina was the sister of the husband of Pieri's sister Virginia and she came from Castroreale in Sicily. They had no children, but for several years they looked after two children of Pieri's sister Gemma who was in Brazil during those years. He was promoted to ordinary professor in the University of Catania in April 1903. After spending eight years in Sicily, Pieri moved to the north of Italy, taking up an appointment in Parma. During these years in Catania [3]:-
... he produced two research papers on algebraic geometry, two book reviews, four papers on logic and foundations of arithmetic, and about seven on foundations of geometry, including two major works axiomatising Euclidean and complex projective geometry.
In fact, although Pieri's main area was projective geometry, and he is an important member of the Italian School of Geometers, however, after he moved to Turin, he became influenced by Giuseppe Peano at the University and Cesare Burali-Forti who was a colleague at the Military Academy. Their influence had led Pieri to study the foundations of geometry. In 1895 he set up an axiomatic system for projective geometry with three undefined terms, namely points, lines and segments. He improved on results of Moritz Pasch and Giuseppe Peano and then, in 1905, he gave the first axiomatic definition of complex projective geometry which does not build on real projective geometry. In 1898 Pieri had published the memoir The principles of the geometry of position through the Academy of Sciences of Turin. Bertrand Russell was impressed by this memoir and wrote, in his Principia:-
This is, in my opinion, the best work on the present subject.
Pieri had been invited to attend both the Congress of Philosophy and the International Congress of Mathematicians in Paris in 1900. He did not attend these conferences but submitted a paper to the first of these on Geometry considered as a purely logical system. It certainly impressed Hans Freudenthal who wrote:-
In the field of the philosophy of sciences the Italian phalanx was supreme: Peano, Burali-Forti, Padoa, Pieri absolutely dominated the discussion.
The first Lobachevsky Prize was awarded to Sophus Lie in 1897. Pieri submitted an entry for the Lobachevsky Prize on the third time the Prize was offered. He received an 'honourable mention', as did Barbarin, Lemoine and Study, while the Prize went to David Hilbert for the 1903 edition of his Die Grundlagen der Geometrie . In 1908 Pieri was honoured by being named Knight of the Crown of Italy.

In 1907 his health had begun to fail and he was unable to teach for three months. However, he recovered and after moving to Parma in 1908 he became both an ordinary professor and director of the School of Projective and Descriptive Geometry with Design. The move from Catania to Parma was not promotion, but Pieri was looking to return to somewhere nearer to his native Tuscany. After he had succeeded in getting his former student Beppo Levi appointed to Parma in 1909 the two cooperated in expanding the university [3]:-
During the next years they worked to enhance the university's offerings in mathematics, creating schools of fundamentals of algebra, of ornamental design and architecture, and of infinitesimal calculus in 1911. By then assistants had been hired for the first two of these, as well as for Pieri's school.
In 1911 Pieri became interested the vector calculus through the work of Cesare Burali-Forti and Roberto Marcolongo. However, around this time his health began to fail and cancer was diagnosed. His mathematical work came to an abrupt end at a time when he was at the height of his creative powers. In early 1912 Bertrand Russell invited Pieri to address the philosophy section of the International Congress of Mathematicians to be held in Cambridge, England in August of that year. Russell wrote (see for example [3]):-
As secretary of the philosophy section of the congress of mathematicians that will be held during the month of August in Cambridge, and as an admirer of your works, I have the honour of earnestly asking you to give a talk and take part in our discussions. The works of Whitehead and me, as you know, are based on the works of the Italian school, and I deeply desire that it will be well represented here in the philosophy section. Have faith, dear sir, in the assurance of my highest esteem.
Pieri, however, was by this time too ill to attend the Congress. Following Pieri's death from cancer in 1913, his colleague and former student Beppo Levi wrote (see for example [3]):-
The work of Pieri was distinguished by carefulness of method, of order, and of rigour. And such were the signs of his character: he was on every occasion sincere, exact, and honest without possible compromise.
Peano in [14] writes:-
Pieri was totally dedicated to science and teaching. He was an untiring worker, honest, and of a singular modesty. When, some twenty years ago, the professors in Italy agitated for higher salaries, Pieri declared that their salaries were already above the work they did and their merit.
We have already noted Pieri's passion for music but he had other hobbies, including climbing. He made a number of assents in the Alps during his time in Turin. Gino Arrighi presents a clear picture of his character:-
Pieri was slightly smaller than usual in stature, bald, myopic, of a very reserved character, taciturn, and always absorbed in his thoughts about the most delicate concerns.
Let us end this biography by quoting from Ugo Cassina who wrote, in 1960:-
More than forty-seven years have passed since the death of Pieri, so that we can better evaluate - from the perspective of time - his collective works and recognise those of major importance which have contributed to place the name of Mario Pieri in the restricted circle of Italian mathematicians well-known in Italy and abroad at the turn of the century. ... [These] works of Pieri have ... major originality [and have] brilliantly withstood the passage of decades and the fashion of the moment.

References (show)

  1. H C Kennedy, Biography in Dictionary of Scientific Biography (New York 1970-1990). See THIS LINK.
  2. H C Kennedy, Peano : Life and Works of Giuseppe Peano (Dordrecht, 1980).
  3. E A Marchisotto and J T Smith, The Legacy of Mario Pieri in Geometry and Arithmetic (Springer, 2007).
  4. M Avellone, A Brigaglia and C Zappulla, The foundations of projective geometry in Italy from De Paolis to Pieri, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 56 (5) (2002), 363-425.
  5. U Bottazzini, Italian geometers and the problem of foundations (1889-1899) (Italian), Bol. Unione Mat. Ital. Sez. A Mat. Soc. Cult. (8) 4 (2) (2001), 281-329.
  6. G Castelnuovo, Mario Pieri, Bollettino della mathesis 5 (1913), 40-41.
  7. L Ingaliso, Mario Pieri's address at the University of Catania, Historia Math. 38 (2) (2011), 232-247.
  8. B Levi, Mario Pieri, Bollettino di bibliographia e storia delle scienze matematiche 15 (1913), 65-74, 16 (1914), 32.
  9. E A Marchisotto, Mario Pieri: the man, the mathematician, the teacher (Italian), Mat. Soc. Cult. Riv. Unione Mat. Ital. (I) 3 (3) (2010), 321-364; 465.
  10. E A Marchisotto, The projective geometry of Mario Pieri: a legacy of Georg Karl Christian von Staudt, Historia Math. 33 (3) (2006), 277-314.
  11. E A Marchisotto, Mario Pieri : His contributions to the foundations and teaching of geometry, Historia Math. 16 (1989), 287-288.
  12. E A Marchisotto, Mario Pieri : His contributions to geometry and foundations of mathematics, Historia Math. 20 (1993), 285-303.
  13. E A Marchisotto, In the shadow of giants: The work of Mario Pieri in the foundations of mathematics, History and Philosophy of Logic 65 (1995), 107-119.
  14. G Peano, Mario Pieri, Academia pro Interlingua, Discussiones 4 (1913), 31-35.
  15. F Skof, Sull'opera scientifica di Mario Pieri, Boll. Un. Mat. Ital. (3) 15 (1960), 63-68.
  16. J T Smith, Definitions and nondefinability in geometry, Amer. Math. Monthly 117 (6) (2010), 475-489.
  17. J-D Voelke, Le théorème fondamental de la géométrie projective: évolution de sa preuve entre 1847 et 1900, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci. 62 (3) (2008), 243-296.

Additional Resources (show)

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update July 2012