# Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky

### Quick Info

Nizhny Novgorod (was Gorky from 1932-1990), Russia

Kazan, Russia

**Nikolai Lobachevsky**published his work on non-Euclidean geometry, the first account of the subject to appear in print.

### Biography

**Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky**'s father Ivan Maksimovich Lobachevsky, worked as a clerk in an office which was involved in land surveying while Nikolai Ivanovich's mother was Praskovia Alexandrovna Lobachevskaya. Nikolai Ivanovich was one of three sons in this poor family. When Nikolai Ivanovich was seven years of age his father died and, in 1800, his mother moved with her three sons to the city of Kazan in western Russia on the edge of Siberia. There the boys attended Kazan Gymnasium, financed by government scholarships, with Nikolai Ivanovich entering the school in 1802.

In 1807 Lobachevsky graduated from the Gymnasium and entered Kazan University as a free student. Kazan State University had been founded in 1804, the result of one of the many reforms of the emperor Alexander I, and it opened in the following year, only two years before Lobachevsky began his undergraduate career. His original intention was to study medicine but he changed to study a broad scientific course involving mathematics and physics. Vinberg writes [44]:-

In the first years the atmosphere in the Department was quite favourable. The students were full of enthusiasm. They studied day and night to compensate for lack of knowledge. The professors, mainly invited from Germany, turned out to be excellent teachers, which was not common. Lobachevsky was highly successful in all courses he took ...One of the excellent professors who had been invited from Germany was Martin Bartels (1769 - 1833) who had been appointed as Professor of Mathematics. Bartels was a school teacher and friend of Gauss, and the two corresponded. We shall return later to discuss ideas of some historians, for example M Kline, that Gauss may have given Lobachevsky hints regarding directions that he might take in his mathematical work through the letters exchanged between Bartels and Gauss. A skilled teacher, Bartels soon interested Lobachevsky in mathematics. We do know that Bartels lectured on the history of mathematics and that he gave a course based on the text by Montucla. Since Euclid's

*Elements*and his theory of parallel lines are discussed in detail in Montucla's book, it seems likely that Lobachevsky's interest in the Fifth Postulate was stimulated by these lectures. Laptev, see [29], has established that Lobachevsky attended this history course given by Bartels.

Lobachevsky received a Master's Degree in physics and mathematics in 1811. In 1814 he was appointed to a lectureship and in 1816 he became an extraordinary professor. In 1822 he was appointed as a full professor [1]:-

... the same year in which he began an administrative career as a member of the committee formed to supervise the construction of new university buildings.Lobachevsky had experienced difficulties during this period at the University of Kazan. Struik writes in [2] that the administration, led by the curator M L Magnitskii:-

... reflected the spirit of the later years of Tsar Alexander I, who was distrustful of modern science and philosophy, particularly that of the German philosopher Immanuel Kant, as evil products of the French Revolution and a menace to orthodox religion. The results at Kazan during the years 1819-26 were factionalism, decay of academic standards, dismissals, and departure of some of the best professors, including ... Bartels ...Despite these difficulties, many brought on according to Vinberg in [44] by Lobachevsky's "upright and independent character", he achieved many things. As well as his vigorous mathematical research, which we shall talk about later in this article, he taught a wide range of topics including mathematics, physics and astronomy. His lectures [44]:-

... were detailed and clear, so that they could be understood even by poorly prepared students.Lobachevsky bought equipment for the physics laboratory, and he purchased books for the library in St Petersburg. He was appointed to important positions within the university such as the dean of the Mathematics and Physics Department between 1820 and 1825 and head librarian from 1825 to 1835. He also served as Head of the Observatory and was clearly strongly influencing policy within the University. However [30]:-

... the clashes with the curator [Magnitskii] continued.In 1826 Tsar Nicholas I became ruler and introduced a more tolerant regime. In that year Magnitskii was dismissed as curator of Kazan University and a new curator M N Musin-Pushkin was appointed. The atmosphere now changed markedly and Musin-Pushkin found in Lobachevsky someone who could work with him in bringing important changes to the university. In 1827 Lobachevsky became rector of Kazan University, a post he was to hold for the next 19 years. The following year he made a speech (which was published in 1832)

*On the most important subjects of education*and this gives clearly what were the ideas in his educational philosophy. Laptev writes in that Lobachevsky [30]:-

... outlined the ideal of the harmonious development of the personality, emphasised the social significance of upbringing and education, and discussed the role of the sciences and the scientist's duty to his country and people.The University of Kazan flourished while Lobachevsky was rector, and this was largely due to his influence. There was a vigorous programme of new building, with a library, an astronomical observatory, new medical facilities and physics, chemistry and anatomy laboratories being constructed. He pressed strongly for higher levels of scientific research and he equally encouraged research in the arts, particularly developing a leading centre for Oriental Studies. There was a marked increase in the number of students and Lobachevsky invested much effort in raising not only the standards of education in the university, but also in the local schools.

Two natural disasters struck the university while he was Rector of Kazan [44]:-

... a cholera epidemic in 1830 and a big fire in 1842. Owing to resolute and reasonable measures taken by Lobachevsky the damage to the University was reduced to a minimum. for his activity during the cholera epidemic Lobachevsky received a message of thanks from the Emperor.The book [5] contains some yearly reports Lobachevsky wrote as rector of Kazan University. Those published are only a small sample taken from the hundreds of pages of manuscript:-

... written in [Lobachevsky's] full, firm hand, with hardly an error, let alone a crossing-out, reports which were an obstacle to real work in the path of all academics then as now.Despite this heavy administrative load, Lobachevsky continued to teach a variety of different topics such as mechanics, hydrodynamics, integration, differential equations, the calculus of variations, and mathematical physics. He even found time to give lectures on physics to the general public during the years 1838 to 1840 but the heavy work-load was to eventually take its toll on his health.

In 1832 Lobachevsky married Lady Varvara Alexejevna Moisieva who came from a wealthy family. At the time of his marriage his wife was a young girl while Lobachevsky was forty years old. The marriage gave them seven children and it is claimed in [1] that the children:-

... and the cost of technological improvements for his estate left him with little money upon his retirement.In [44] Vinberg writes:-

The couple lived in a big three-storey house and received a lot of guests with lavish hospitality. However Lobachevsky was not lucky in his marriage.After Lobachevsky retired in 1846 (essentially dismissed by the University of Kazan), his health rapidly deteriorated. Matveev, in his article [34], quotes many records concerning Lobachevsky's estate which he purchased at Slobodka. There are many claims by biographers that:-

Lobachevsky was an impractical manager who jeopardised his financial position by purchasing the estate while living on a pension; that he had no time to look after the estate and took little interest in it; that he was left in poverty and ignored by the local officials, etc.But Matveev shows that these claims are totally unjustified. Soon after he retired, however, his favourite eldest son died and Lobachevsky was hit hard by this tragedy. The illness that he suffered from became progressively worse and led to blindness. These and financial difficulties added to the heavy burdens he had to bear over his last years. His great mathematical achievements, which we shall now discuss, were not recognised in his lifetime and he died without having any notion of the fame and importance that his work would achieve.

Since Euclid's axiomatic formulation of geometry mathematicians had been trying to prove his fifth postulate as a theorem deduced from the other four axioms. The fifth postulate states that given a line and a point not on the line, a unique line can be drawn through the point parallel to the given line. Lobachevsky did not try to prove this postulate as a theorem. Instead he studied geometry in which the fifth postulate does not necessarily hold. Lobachevsky categorised euclidean as a special case of this more general geometry.

His major work,

*Geometriya*completed in 1823, was not published in its original form until 1909. On 11 February 1826, in the session of the Department of Physico-Mathematical Sciences at Kazan University, Lobachevsky requested that his work about a new geometry was heard and his paper

*A concise outline of the foundations of geometry*was sent to referees. The text of this paper has not survived but the ideas were incorporated, perhaps in a modified form, in Lobachevsky's first publication on hyperbolic geometry. He published this work on non-euclidean geometry, the first account of the subject to appear in print, in 1829. It was published in the

*Kazan Messenger*but rejected by Ostrogradski when it was submitted for publication by the St Petersburg Academy of Sciences.

In 1834 Lobachevsky found a method for the approximation of the roots of algebraic equations. This method of numerical solution of algebraic equations, developed independently by Gräffe to answer a prize question of the Berlin Academy, is today a particularly suitable method for using computers to solve such problems. This method is today called the Dandelin-Gräffe method since Dandelin also independently investigated it, but only in Russia does the method appear to be named after Lobachevsky who is the third independent discoverer. See [24] for a discussion of the method and its three discoverers.

In 1837 Lobachevsky published his article

*Géométrie imaginaire*Ⓣ and a summary of his new geometry

*Geometrische Untersuchungen zur Theorie der Parellellinien*Ⓣ was published in Berlin in 1840. This last publication greatly impressed Gauss but much has been written about Gauss's role in the discovery of non-euclidean geometry which is just simply false. There is a coincidence which arises from the fact that we know that Gauss himself discovered non-euclidean geometry but told very few people, only his closest friends. Two of his friends were Farkas Bolyai, the father of János Bolyai (an independent discoverer of non-euclidean geometry), and Bartels who was Lobachevsky's teacher. This coincidence has prompted speculation that both Lobachevsky and Bolyai were led to their discoveries by Gauss. M Kline has put forward this theory but it has been refuted in several works; see for example [28]. Also Laptev in [29] has examined the correspondence between Bartels and Gauss and shown that Bartels did not know about Gauss's results in non-euclidean geometry.

There are other claims made about Lobachevsky and the discovery of non-euclidean geometry which have been recently refuted. For example in [25] the claims that Lobachevsky was in correspondence with Gauss ( Gauss appreciated Lobachevsky's works very highly but had no personal correspondence with him), that Gauss studied Russian to read Lobachevsky's Russian papers as claimed for example in [1] (actually, Gauss had studied Russian before he had even heard of Lobachevsky), and that Gauss was a "good propagandist" of Lobachevsky's works in Germany (Gauss never commented publicly on Lobachevsky's work) are shown to be false.

The story of how Lobachevsky's hyperbolic geometry came to be accepted is a complex one and this biography is not the place in which to go into details, but we shall note the main events. In 1866, ten years after Lobachevsky's death, Hoüel published a French translation of Lobachevsky's

*Geometrische Untersuchungen*Ⓣ together with some of Gauss's correspondence on non-euclidean geometry. Beltrami, in 1868, gave a concrete realisation of Lobachevsky's geometry. Weierstrass led a seminar on Lobachevsky's geometry in 1870 which was attended by Klein and, two years later, after Klein and Lie had discussed these new generalisations of geometry in Paris, Klein produced his general view of geometry as the properties invariant under the action of some group of transformations in the

*Erlanger Programm*. There were two further major contributions to Lobachevsky's geometry by Poincaré in 1882 and 1887. Perhaps these finally mark the acceptance of Lobachevsky's ideas which would eventually be seen as vital steps in freeing the thinking of mathematicians so that relativity theory had a natural mathematical foundation.

### References (show)

- B A Rosenfeld, Biography in
*Dictionary of Scientific Biography*(New York 1970-1990). See THIS LINK. - Biography in
*Encyclopaedia Britannica.*http://www.britannica.com/biography/Nikolay-Ivanovich-Lobachevsky - R Bonola,
*Non-Euclidean Geometry*(1955). - F Engel,
*N I Lobatschewskij: Zwei geometrische Abhandlungen*(1898-99) (2 volumes). - B V Fedorenko,
*New documents for the biography of N I Lobachevskii*(Russian) (Leningrad, 1988). - D A Gudkov,
*N I Lobachevskii, Biography puzzles*(Nizhnii Novgorod, 1992). - V F Kagan,
*Lobachevsky*(Moscow- Leningrad, 1948). - A G Karimullin and B L Laptev,
*What N I Lobachevskii read : A list of the books and journals lent to N I Lobachevskii by Kazan University Library*(Russian), (Kazan, 1979). - G Kasdorf, Lobachevskii, in H Wussing and W Arnold,
*Biographien bedeutender Mathematiker*(Berlin, 1983). - T I Kovaleva and N F Filatov,
*N I Lobachevskii and the Nizhegorod region at the turn of the 18th-19th centuries*(Russian) (Nizhnii Novgorod, 1992). - A V Vasilev,
*Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii : 1792-1856*'Nauka' (Moscow, 1992). - 12.2.1981-125 : Todestag von Nikolai Iwanowitsch Lobatschewski,
*Mitt. Math. Ges. DDR No.***1**(1985), 19-31. - V A Bazhanov, Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii (Russian),
*Priroda*(7) (1993), 1,2,3. - V A Bazhanov, The imaginary geometry of N I Lobachevskii and the imaginary logic of N A Vasiliev,
*Modern Logic***4**(2) (1994), 148-156. - G Bizám, 'Aus dem Nichts habe ich eine neue, andere Welt erschaffen.' Was ist die Bolyai-Lobatschewskische Geometrie?, in
*Grosse Augenblicke aus der Geschichte der Mathematik*(Mannheim, 1990), 103-138. - N A Chernikov, Introduction of Lobachevskii geometry into the theory of gravitation,
*Soviet J. Particles and Nuclei***23**(5) (1992), 507-521. - N Daniels, Lobachevsky : some anticipations of later views on the relation between geometry and physics,
*Isis***66**(231) (1975), 75-85. - A Dou, The 'Geometrische Untersuchungen' of Lobachevskii (Spanish),
*Mathematical contributions*(Madrid, 1994), 345-355. - A Drago, The organization of theory in L Carnot and Lobachevskii (Italian),
*Epistemology of mathematics : 1992-1993 Seminars*(Rome, 1994), 215-224. - L E Evtushik and A K Rybnikov, The influence of Lobachevskii's ideas on the development of differential geometry,
*Moscow Univ. Math. Bull.***49**(2) (1994), 1-9. - K Fili, Lobachevskii's 'imaginary' geometry and the Russian avant-garde (Russian),
*Voprosy Istor. Estestvoznan. i Tekhn.*(4) (1992), 43-48. - B V Gnedenko, N I Lobachevskii as an educator and a representative of the Enlightenment,
*Moscow Univ. Math. Bull.***49**(2) (1994), 10-16. - G B Halsted, Biography. Lobachevsky,
*Amer. Math. Monthly***2**(1895), 137-137. - A S Householder, Dandelin, Lobachevskii, or Gräffe?,
*Amer. Math. Monthly***66**(1959), 464-466. - G E Izotov, Legends and reality in Lobachevskii's biography (Russian),
*Priroda*(7) (1993), 4-11. - G E Izotov, On the history of the publishing by N I Lobachevskii of his works on 'imaginary' geometry (Russian),
*Voprosy Istor. Estestvoznan. i Tekhn.*(4) (1992), 36-43. - S B Kadomtsev, E G Poznyak, and A G Popov, Lobachevskii's geometry: the discovery and a path to the present (Russian),
*Priroda*(7) (1993), 19-27. - G Krou, Lobachevskii in the context of his epoch (Russian),
*Priroda*(7) (1993), 11-18. - B L Laptev, Bartels and the shaping of the geometric ideas of Lobachevskii (Russian), in
*Dedicated to the memory of Lobachevskii***1**(Kazan, 1992), 35-40. - B L Laptev, Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii, in
*Great Soviet Encyclopedia***14**(New York, 1977), 617-618. - N A Litsis, Philosophical problems of mathematics in the works of N I Lobachevskii (Russian),
*Latvijas PSR Ziniatn. Akad. Viestis***3(404)**(1981), 76-83. - O V Manturov, Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii (on the bicentenary of his birth) (Russian),
*Uspekhi Mat. Nauk***48**2(290) (1993), 5-16 - O V Manturov, Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii (on the bicentenary of his birth),
*Russian Math. Surveys***48**(2) (1993), 1-13. - Yu I Matveev, Lobachevskii's estate Slobodka (outlines of a portrait of a scholar) (Russian),
*Priroda*(3) (1987), 27-33. - B Mayorga, Lobachevskii and non-Euclidean geometry (Spanish),
*Lect. Mat.***15**(1) (1994), 29-43. - J M Montesinos Amilibia, Non-Euclidean geometries : Gauss, Lobachevskii and Bolyai (Spanish), in
*History of mathematics in the XIXth century*(Part 1) (Madrid, 1992), 65-114. - A P Norden and A P Shirokov, The legacy of N I Lobachevskii and the activity of Kazan geometers (Russian),
*Uspekhi Mat. Nauk***48**2(290) (1993),47-74. - A P Norden and A P Shirokov, The legacy of N I Lobachevskii and the activity of Kazan geometers,
*Russian Math. Surveys***48**(2) (1993), 47-74. - V Ya Perminov, The philosophical and methodological thought of N I Lobachevsky,
*Philos. Math.*(3)**5**(1) (1997), 3-20. - G M Polotovskii, Who was the father of Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii? : On D A Gudkov's book 'N I Lobachevskii. Riddles of the biography' (Russian),
*Voprosy Istor. Estestvoznan. i Tekhn.*(4) (1992), 30-36. - G Dzh Tarzimanova, N I Lobachevskii and A Ya Kupfer (Russian), in
*Dedicated to the memory of Lobachevskii*1 (Kazan, 1992), 87-96. - R Taton, Lobatchevski et la diffusion des géometries non-euclidiennes, in
*The Spanish scientist before the history of science*(Madrid, 1980), 39-46. - V V Vishnevskii, On the bicentenary of N I Lobachevskii : Lessons and results (Russian),
*Tr. Geom. Semin. No.***23**(1997), 23-32. - E B Vinberg, Nikolaj Lobachevskii : On the occasion of his 200th anniversary,
*European Mathematical Society Newsletter***6**(1992), 8-9. - A Vucinich, Nicolai Ivanovich Lobachevskii: The Man Behind the First Non-Euclidean Geometry,
*Isis***53**(1962), 465-481.

### Additional Resources (show)

Other pages about Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky:

Other websites about Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky:

### Honours (show)

Honours awarded to Nikolai Ivanovich Lobachevsky

### Cross-references (show)

- History Topics: An overview of the history of mathematics
- History Topics: Non-Euclidean geometry
- History Topics: The development of group theory
- History Topics: The function concept
- Societies: Kazan Physico-mathematical Society
- Other: Earliest Known Uses of Some of the Words of Mathematics (I)
- Other: Earliest Known Uses of Some of the Words of Mathematics (P)
- Other: Jeff Miller's Mathematicians on Postage Stamps

Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson

Last Update February 2000

Last Update February 2000