Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer
Figueres, Girona, Spain
BiographyFerran Sunyer's parents were Ricard Sunyer i Molinas (1884-1914), a medical doctor, and Àngela Balaguer i Masdevall (1890-1955). Maria Carbona i Balaguer, Àngels Carbona i Balaguer and Ferran Carbona i Balaguer (1909-1979) were first cousins of Ferran Sunyer who were orphaned at a young age and brought up by Àngela Balaguer. Perhaps saying they were orphaned is not quite true since their father had deserted the family making no provision for his wife and children. His wife, Clara Balaguer, the only sister of Àngela Balaguer, died of tuberculosis shortly after this. Ferran Carbona was three years older than Ferran Sunyer, the subject of this biography. He went on to become a chemical engineer who had left-wing views and fought for the Republicans during the Spanish Civil War. This, we will see, is not irrelevant to a later positive episode in Ferran Sunyer's life.
Ricard Sunyer had died of tuberculosis, a few months before the death of Àngela's sister, when his son Ferran was only two years old. Ricard Sunyer had followed the family tradition of becoming a physician, having a father and grandfather who were also doctors. The family were well off and owned land in Vilajoan, south of Figueres, a town near the south coast of Spain about 20 km from the border with France. Ferran Sunyer was born with a severe motor disability which soon became apparent. His doctors thought the young child would not live but, although severely physically disabled, it quickly became clear that the young child was not mentally disabled. However, the doctors recommended that he should not be educated since the strain might prove fatal. Anyway, they said, what was the point of educating a child who was so severely disabled that he would never be able to do anything.
Ferran's mother was very surprised to discover that when he reached the age of four he was able to read. Although nobody had tried to teach him, the young child had been able to learn by himself. From this time on his mother decided that she would ignore the advice of the doctors and educate her son herself. There would have been no possibility of Ferran attending school. He could not eat himself, he could not move unless wheeled around by family members in a wheelchair and, although he did learn to speak, it was only something he did with the greatest difficulty. Certainly no school at this time would have been able to cope with such a severely disabled child. The family moved to Barcelona where Sunyer lived for the rest of his life. However, he did love to spend time during the summers on the estate in Vilajoan.
We have said that Sunyer was educated by his mother but as she knew no mathematics we need to try to understand how this severely disabled boy developed into what many consider to be the leading Spanish mathematician of his day. He was totally self-educated without the assistance of anyone who knew any mathematics. Antoni Malet writes in :-
When the Sunyer i Balaguer family moved to Barcelona, it is very likely that Ferran Sunyer studied mathematics and experimental science from the notes and textbooks of his cousin Ferran Carbona, who earned a degree in chemical engineering. Sunyer had practically no use of his hands. With time he learned to pick up sheets of paper that he could move on the desk. On a normal working day, in the morning he was left in his room with his books open and the articles laid out that he wished to read. He worked mentally. Occasionally, when he wanted to remember a formula or a partial result, he dictated it. While his mother was alive, she, who knew absolutely nothing about mathematics, would carefully copy those formulas in a notebook; after her death, his cousins continued the practice. That notebook full of formulas was the only tool Sunyer used in his work. When he had an article ready, 'finished in his head', he dictated the text, inserting in it formulas from the notebook.In 1933 he read the seventh edition of Joseph Alfred Serret's Cours d'algèbre supérieure Ⓣ which, we must assume, his cousin had borrowed for him from the library of the University of Barcelona. Discovering an error on the book, Sunyer found a correct proof and, in early 1934, sent a short paper to Émile Picard who was the secretary of the Académie des Sciences in Paris. A covering letter explained that Sunyer hoped that the paper might be published but, if that was not possible, perhaps he might receive an opinion on it. Picard (who was 77 years old at this time) never replied to Sunyer and this might have dispirited anyone with less determination but, despite the difficulties he worked under, it did not prevent him from continuing to undertake research.
In December 1938 Sunyer made another attempt to have a paper published. In fact he had written two papers and he sent them to Jacques Hadamard with the following letter, the original version of which, with its errors in the French, is given in :
Monsieur Jacques Hadamard,He got a very positive and encouraging reply from Hadamard who arranged for one of his papers, Sur une classe de transformations des formules de sommabilité Ⓣ, to be published in the Comptes Rendus of the Paris Academy of Sciences. It was published in 1939 and in it Sunyer constructed a class of methods of analytic continuation. When we say that he received a reply from Hadamard we should note that he received it indirectly since Barcelona was captured by Franco's forces in January 1939 and Hadamard's letter never reached him. However, Sunyer's cousin, Ferran Carbona, had fled to Paris so that he could continue to support the Republican forces using his chemical knowledge to manufacture ammunition. He was able to get news to Sunyer regarding Hadamard's response in which he encouraged Sunyer to continue to undertake research.
Sir: I send you enclosed two original notes, if you think them sufficiently interesting please be so kind as to communicate them to the Academy of Sciences. In any case, I would be infinitely grateful to your extreme kindness if you allowed me to know your authoritative and always valuable opinion, which, because my training has been undertaken completely by self-study, would be of even greater usefulness for me. The war of invasion that the Iberian people are suffering has not allowed me to obtain all the works and memoirs that I would desire. Therefore excuse me, Sir, if you find any fault in the references in these notes.
With all my anticipated thanks, I send you, Sir, the assurance of my esteem most marked by admiration.
In the same year, 1939, Sunyer's first paper in Spanish was published, namely On a theorem of Professor Picard (Spanish), in which he proved the "little" Picard theorem by applying the theory of normal families in a new way. This paper was reviewed for Mathematical Reviews by Ralph Philip Boas Jr so, at this early stage, Boas became familiar with Sunyer's work. In 1942 Sunyer published On some results concerning the theorems of Picard, Landau and Schottky and on a criterion of quasinormality (Spanish). In this paper, using a theorem of Rolf Nevanlinna, Sunyer proved a result about meromorphic functions, proved a criterion for quasi-normality of a family of meromorphic functions, and, deduced from this extensions of Landau's theorem and Schottky's theorem. This paper was also reviewed for Mathematical Reviews by Ralph Philip Boas Jr but, because at this time he was working for the military, he published the review under the name E S Pondiczery.
When Germany invaded France in 1940 Hadamard fled the country and went to the United States where he had a temporary position at Columbia University in New York. Sunyer lost contact with him at this time and it was only after Hadamard had spent a year in England and returned to Paris as soon as the war ended that he was able to resume contact sending him a memoir on lacunary Taylor series. This renewed contact, begun in 1946, was extremely important to Sunyer since Hadamard put him in contact with Szolem Mandelbrojt. He advised Sunyer on improvements to his mathematical style and also improvements to his French. Two notes with results from the memoir on lacunary Taylor series were quickly published. They were both called Sur la substitution d'une valeur exceptionnelle par une propriété lacunaire Ⓣ (1947). Sunyer continued to publish papers such as On a class of transformations of the algorithms for summation of analytic series (Spanish) (1948), On the exclusion of an exceptional function by a gap condition (Spanish) (1948), Une généralisation des fonctions presque-périodiques Ⓣ (1949), A new generalization of almost periodic functions (Catalan) (1949), and Properties of entire functions (of finite order) represented by lacunary Taylor series (Spanish) (1949). These led to his being awarded the Agell Prize by the Academy of Barcelona in 1947 and 1948, then a prize by the province of Zaragoza in 1950.
The Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (CSIC), a similar body to the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), was set up following the Spanish Civil War. It followed the principles of the Franco regime, was politicised and emphasised applied research. Sunyer applied for a position in the CSIC in January 1948. He was given a temporary position with a very small stipend. Rey Pastor accepted a position at CSIC and invited Ernest Corominas to join him at the CSIC so, in 1952, Corominas, who had left Spain when Barcelona fell to Franco's army, returned to Barcelona taking up a position at the CSIC. Sunyer and Corominas produced a remarkable result published in two joint papers in which they proved:
If f(x) is infinitely differentiable, and some derivative (of order depending on x) vanishes at each x, then f(x) is a polynomial.They announced this result, and other related results, in Sur des conditions pour qu'une fonction infiniment dérivable soit un polynome Ⓣ but the full proof appears in the Spanish paper Conditions for an infinitely differentiable function to be a polynomial. Both papers were published in 1954.
Let us record at this point how the three women, first Sunyer's mother (she died in 1955) and then his two cousins, cared for him and gave him the opportunity to undertake mathematical research. Every day they had to lift him from his bed to his chair, wash and clothe him, feed him and give him the materials he wanted to read. However, despite this one should not think that he was permanently confined to his home. He spent the summers in Vilajoan where he enjoyed being taken into the countryside. He was also taken to mathematics conferences and attended the annual meetings of the Spanish Mathematical Society. He attended the Réunion des Mathématiciens d'Expression Latine in Nice in 1957 where he talked with Szolem Mandelbrojt and said he would like to meet Wacław Sierpinski since he had discovered an error in a proof in Sierpinski's book Hypothèse du continu Ⓣ which had been published in 1934. Mandelbrojt was somewhat reluctant but, with Sunyer determined to talk to Sierpinski, the meeting took place. As a result Sierpinski published a note in which he wrote:-
Regarding the following proof, M Sunyer Balaguer has noted that it is not correct ... Stanisłas Saks was killed by the Gestapo in November 1942 and his manuscripts no longer exist. I myself lost my library and my archives in the flames in 1944. It is therefore impossible to determine today what was the proof of S Saks. In any case it is remarkable that thanks to M Sunyer Balaguer, the error has been found 23 years after the appearance of the first edition of my book.Despite only being able to speak with great difficulty, Sunyer was able to lecture at conferences. He did this by simply talking to the audience while someone assisted by writing formulas on the blackboard. This could result in a publication, written up by one of the mathematicians attending the conference.
Through Mandelbrojt, Sunyer had been put in contact with Archibald James Macintyre around 1956. At this time Archibald Macintyre was in Aberdeen but their correspondence continued after Archibald Macintyre and his wife were appointed to the University of Cincinnati in the United States in 1958. In the following year Macintyre invited Sunyer to make a research visit to the United States in exchange for an American researcher visiting Barcelona. Sunyer was keen make the visit but, sadly, the University of Barcelona and CSIC both rejected his application. He was, however, able to attend further conferences abroad such as in Florence, and an harmonic analysis meeting in Oberwolfach in 1965.
We mentioned above that Ralph Philip Boas Jr was familiar with Sunyer's work and it is worth recording that he was so taken with the 1954 result of Corominas and Sunyer quoted above that he wrote a whole book around it, namely A primer of real functions (1960). I S Gál writes :-
Long before this book was published Professor Boas told me of his plans to write a new Carus monograph on a less specialized topic than those presented in the last few volumes. He had already decided to write a first introduction to real variable theory and in order to have a guiding line he planned to include everything which is necessary to formulate and prove [the 1954 result of Corominas and Sunyer].Despite his severe disability, Sunyer became more integrated into the mathematical community as the years went on and several mathematicians would visit him in his home in Barcelona. We also note that, during the last five years of his life 1962-67, he held research grants from the Office of Naval Research of the United States Navy. His application for these grants had been strongly supported by Boas. However, he was always marginalised within the Spanish mathematical community. Antoni Malet suggests (see  and ) that this was partly due to his disability and partly due to his insistence on promoting the Catalan language and Catalan spelling in his writings. It was not until one month before his death that Sunyer was promoted to Scientific Researcher in CSIC.
After his death, his cousins Maria Carbona i Balaguer and Àngels Carbona i Balaguer created the Foundation Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer in 1983. This Foundation was integrated into the Institut d"Estudis Catalans in 1991. From 1993 The Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer Prize has been awarded for a mathematical monograph of an expository nature presenting the latest developments in an active area of research in Mathematics.
We end our biography by quoting from Victor Pambuccian's review of  where he gives a good summary of Sunyer's mathematical contributions (see ):-
The bulk of his work, published between 1939 and 1970, is on topics in the theory of entire and meromorphic functions, where his main tendency is that of generalizing important results, and is grouped in the volume under review into eight sections: (i) "miscellaneous papers", one of which contains generalizations of the theorems of Landau, Schottky, Picard, and of Montel's normality criterion, another on a new method for the summation of power series, but also a paper that falls entirely outside of the realm of analysis (to which all other papers are devoted), answering a question raised by Sierpinski in 1951 on order types; (ii) and (iii), spread over 220 pages, the study of exceptional values of an entire function as influenced by the lacunarity of the Taylor (or Dirichlet) series defining it, (ii) containing F Sunyer i Balaguer's 'Acta Mathematica' paper of 1952; (iv) work on the behaviour of an entire function and its derivatives and primitives along Borel-Valiron directions of maximal type; (v) generalizations of S Mandelbrojt's fundamental inequality (vi) topics in the theory of entire functions and overconvergence; (vii) generalizations of quasi-periodic and elliptic functions; (viii) differentiable functions of a real variable, containing a lovely result (the only one with a co-author, E Corominas) published in 1954) ...
- M Castellet (ed.), Selecta Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer (Catalan) (Institut d'Estudis Catalans. Secció de Ciències i Tecnologia, Barcelona, 2012).
- A Malet, Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer (Catalan) (Societat Catalana de Matematiques and Societat Catalana d'Historia de la Ciencia i de la Tecnic, Barcelona, 1995).
- I S Gál, Review: A primer of real functions, by Ralph Philip Boas Jr., Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 68 (1) (1962), 10-12.
- A Malet, Mathematics and Francoism: the interior exile of the mathematician Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer, Lett. Mat. Int. 1 (2013),127-135.
- A Malet, Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer (1912-1967) and Spanish Mathematics After the Civil War, Mathematical Intelligencer 20 (2) (1998), 23-29.
- M Mazzotti, Review: Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer, by Antoni Malet, The British Journal for the History of Science 31 (1) (1998), 100-101.
- V V Pambuccian, Review: Selecta Ferran Sunyer i Balaguer, by M Castellet (ed.), Mathematical Reviews MR2976624.
Additional Resources (show)
Written by J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update February 2017
Last Update February 2017