André Abraham Weil
Quick Info
Paris, France
Princeton, New Jersey, USA
Biography
André Weil was born in Paris, the son of Jewish parents. His mother, Salomea Reinherz (1879-1965) known as Selma, came from a family of Russian Jews who had emigrated to Austria, while his father, Bernard Bernhard Weil (1872-1955), was a medical doctor whose family had lived in Strasbourg, Alsace.More details of Bernard and Selma Weil are given at THIS LINK.
where details are also given of André's sister Simone Adolphine Weil (1909-1943). We should mention that the Weil family originally used the spelling Weill, for example André's grandfather was Abraham Weill. The Weil family being from Alsace had the right to opt for French nationality and they had done this and moved to Paris. Bernard and Selma Weil were married in Paris in 1905. When André was born in the following year, in addition to his parents, his paternal grandmother and several uncles were living in Paris but his paternal grandfather Abraham Weill had died in Strasbourg. André's maternal grandmother Hermine Reinherz, who was an excellent pianist, lived in his family home with the Weil family which, until 1912, was on the Boulevard de Strasbourg.
André's mother supervised his education for the first few years of his life and he had learned to read between the ages of 4 and 5. When he was six years old in 1912 [6]:-
... my mother chose an exceptional elementary teacher, Mademoiselle Chaintreuil, who taught the tenth form [the second class] at the Lycée Montaigne. After several months of tutoring, she deemed me capable, even though I was a little too young, of joining her class at the lycée.After this first year at the lycée, the family went to Ballaigues in Switzerland for their summer holidays. The family moved from the Boulevard de Strasbourg to the Boulevard Saint-Michel before André began his second year at the lycée. Having done so well in this first year, he missed out a form and was put into the top section taught by M Monbeig [6]:-
He was an exceptional teacher, full of unconventional ideas.During the summer vacation of 1914 World War I broke out. André's father became an army doctor tending the wounded soldiers. He worked in a variety of military hospitals and André, his mother and sister (and usually his grandmother), always moved to be with Bernard Weil. André fell in love with mathematics at an early age, and he writes that by the age of ten he was passionately addicted to it [6]:-
Once when I took a painful fall, my sister Simone could think of nothing for it but to run and fetch my algebra book, to comfort me.When Bernard was sent to Algeria the family didn't go with him but went to Chartes where André attended the lycée. By October 1917 when his father had returned to France, the family moved to Laval. In the following year he was tutored privately before the family returned to their home in Paris. Again he received private tutoring before entering M Collin's class at the Lycée Saint-Louis. It was in this school that studied the parts of mathematics that he had missed out in the studies he had made on his own. There were other things of importance in his life as well as mathematics, however, for he loved to travel. By the age of sixteen he had read the 'Bhagavad Gita' in the original Sanskrit. He had taught himself classical Greek, read Homer and Plato in Greek, and had also taught himself Latin. At meal times the family often conversed in German and English. He also loved European literature, art and music. In 1921, his final year at the Lycée Saint-Louis, he met Jacques Hadamard who gave him good advice from that time on. Every year Weil won the mathematics prize and chose himself (with Hadamard's advice) books for his prize. He chose the three volumes of Camille Jordan's Cours d'Analyse as well as William Thomson and Peter Guthrie Tait's two-volume Treatise of Natural Philosophy. At this time relativity was an exciting new topic and he read Arthur Eddington's description of "Einstein's theory". He graduated from the Lycée Saint-Louis in 1922 and, later that year, Weil entered the École Normale Supérieure in Paris. Weil writes [6]:-
At the "École", as we used to call it, the students were divided into groups sharing quarters. My first concern, even before school started, was to find companionable study mates. There were five of us ...The four others were Yves Rocard, Jean Delsarte, Paul Labérenne (1902-1985), and Jean Barbotte. Right from the time he entered the École Normale Supérieure, Weil attended Hadamard's seminar at the Collège de France. He gave a talk to this seminar on domains of convergence of power series in several complex variables. Among the mathematics courses he attended were those of Henri-Léon Lebesgue and Charles-Émile Picard. However, he continued to have interests outside mathematics and took a course in Sanskrit at the Sorbonne. He graduated in 1925 being ranked first in the class despite returning a blank paper for rational mechanics which he did not consider to be part of mathematics.
After graduating he spent the summer vacation walking in the French Alps, always taking a notebook with him in which he made his mathematical calculations. At this time he was particularly fascinated by solving Diophantine equations. After the summer vacation he went to Rome where he spent six months supported by a scholarship from the Sorbonne. He attended lectures by Vito Volterra and Francesco Severi, and gave a lecture on the Mordell conjecture. However, he certainly didn't devote all his time to mathematics for he took the opportunity to study Italian painting. A Rockefeller Foundation fellowship funded a visit to Göttingen where spent most of 1927 and produced his first substantial piece of mathematical research on the theory of algebraic curves. In Göttingen he met Richard Courant, Emmy Noether and others, profiting from discussions with them.
He then undertook research for his doctorate in the University of Paris, supervised by Jacques Hadamard. He developed for his thesis the ideas on the theory of algebraic curves which he had begun to study at Göttingen. However, Hadamard wanted his brilliant student to aim higher and try to prove the Mordell Conjecture. Weil chose not to follow his supervisor's advice. He wrote later:-
My decision was a wise one: it was to take more than half a century to prove Mordell's Conjecture.He received his doctorate from Paris in 1928 for his thesis Arithmétique des courbes algébriques Ⓣ. At this time military service was compulsory in France, so Weil undertook these duties in the year 1928-29, leaving with the rank of lieutenant. He then taught at different universities, for example the Aligarh Muslim University in India from 1930 to 1932. He had first discussed with Syed Masood, the Minister of Education for Hyderabad, obtaining an appointment to a chair in French Civilization at Aligarh University but, despite the promise, he received a telegram from Syed Masood:-
Impossible to create chair of French civilisation. Mathematics chair open.He took every opportunity to make the most of these years [11]:-
He used to the hilt the opportunity to immerse himself in all aspects of India: culture, religion, literature, people, history, scenery, archaeology, and so on, travelling all over, often under primitive conditions.Returning to France after the two years in India, he worked at the University of Strasbourg from 1933 until the outbreak of World War II. Henri Cartan was on the staff at Strasbourg at this time and the two often discussed teaching. It was here that he became involved with the famous group of mathematicians writing under the name Nicolas Bourbaki. Henri Cartan described how the idea came about [4]:-
André Weil and I were both at the University of Strasbourg in 1934. I often talked with him about the course on differential and integral calculus that I was teaching. ... I often wondered about the best way to teach this course because the existing textbooks were not satisfactory ... I discussed my concerns several times with André Weil. One beautiful day he told me, "I've had it, we need to fix this for good. We need to write a good textbook an analysis. Then you'll stop complaining!"We give more details of the Bourbaki collaboration below.
One of the founders of Bourbaki was René de Possel. René was married to Eveline and Weil met her when Bourbaki was being set up. René and Eveline were divorced and, after waiting a considerable time for the divorce to come through, Weil married Eveline de Possel on 30 October 1937. They had two daughters, Sylvie (born 12 September 1942) and Nicolette born (6 December 1946).
The war was a disaster for Weil who had decided before hostilities broke out that he would avoid military service by going to the United States. However, he was in Finland, visiting Rolf Nevanlinna and Lars Ahlfors, when war was declared. He didn't want to return to France to avoid being forced into the army, but it was not a simple matter to escape from the war in Europe at this time. Weil was arrested in Finland in November 1939 and when letters in Russian were found in his room (they were actually from Pontryagin describing mathematical research) things looked pretty black. Weil himself wrote:-
The manuscripts they found appeared suspicious - like those of Sophus Lie, arrested on charges of spying in Paris, in 1870. They also found several rolls of stenotypewritten paper at the bottom of a closet. When I said these were the text of a Balzac novel, the explanation must have seemed far-fetched. There was also a letter in Russian, from Pontryagin, I believe, in response to a letter I had written at the beginning of the summer regarding a possible visit to Leningrad; and a packet of calling cards belonging to Nicolas Bourbaki, member of the Royal Academy of Poldavia ...One day Nevanlinna was told that they were about to execute Weil as a spy, and he was able to persuade the authorities to deport Weil instead. He was released from prison on 12 December 1939 and he was sent first to Sweden, then to England before finally being sent back to France where he was put in prison. Borel writes [12]:-
His conditions in prison, at first somewhat hard, gradually improved: he could communicate with, and occasionally see, his family, had a lively correspondence with his sister, and could receive some books and work. At that time, he proved one of his most famous results, the "Riemann hypothesis for curves over finite fields."A letter that Weil wrote while in prison at Rouen is at THIS LINK.
Weil was certainly in great danger at this time, partly because he was Jewish, partly because he had a sister Simone Weil who was a mystic philosopher and a leading figure in the French Resistance. The dangers of his predicament made Weil decide that being in the army was a better bet and he was able to argue successfully for his release on the condition that indeed he did join the army. On 3 May 1940 he was tried in Rouen. Élie Cartan went to Rouen to testify in his favour at his trial. He was released from prison and became an army private. Having used the army as a reason to get out of prison, Weil had no intention of serving any longer than he possibly could. As soon as the chance to escape to the United States came, he took it at once travelling there with his wife and parents in January 1941. In the United States, supported by the Rockefeller Foundation, he went to Pennsylvania where he taught from 1941 at Haverford College and then at Lehigh University. In 1945 he accepted a position in São Paulo University, Brazil, where he remained until 1947. In 1947 Weil returned to the United States and he was appointed to the faculty of the University of Chicago, a position he continued to hold until 1958. Shiing-Shen Chern writes [14]:-
We became colleagues at the University of Chicago during the Stone period. Under Stone's leadership Chicago became an active mathematical centre with excellent students. We had constant contact and took long walks along the south coast of Lake Michigan when it was still safe.From 1958 he worked at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton University. He retired in 1976, becoming Professor Emeritus at that time.
Weil's research was in number theory, algebraic geometry and group theory. His work is summarised in [55]:-
Beginning in the 1940s, Weil started the rapid advance of algebraic geometry and number theory by laying the foundations for abstract algebraic geometry and the modern theory of abelian varieties. His work on algebraic curves has influenced a wide variety of areas, including some outside mathematics, such as elementary particle physics and string theory.In fact Weil's work in this area was basic to work by mathematicians such as Shing-Tung Yau who was awarded a Fields Medal in 1982 for work in three dimensional algebraic geometry which has major applications to quantum field theory. Yau is not the only mathematician who received a Fields Medal for work which continued that begun by Weil. In 1978 Pierre Deligne was awarded a Fields Medal for solving the Weil Conjectures. Again we quote [55] for a description of Weil's fundamental contribution:-
One of Weil's major achievements was his proof of the Riemann hypothesis for the congruence zeta functions of algebraic function fields. In 1949 he raised certain conjectures about the congruence zeta function of algebraic varieties over finite fields. These Weil conjectures, as they came to be called, grew out of his deep insight into the topology of algebraic varieties and provided guiding principles for subsequent developments in the field.Weil's work on bringing together number theory and algebraic geometry was highly fruitful. The foundations of many topics studied in depth today were laid by Weil in this work, such as the foundations of the theory of modular forms, automorphic functions and automorphic representations. However, Weil's work was of major importance in a number of other new mathematical topics. He contributed substantially to topology, differential geometry and complex analytic geometry. It was not just to these areas that he contributed but, even more importantly, his work brought out fundamental relationships between the areas when he studied harmonic analysis on topological groups and characteristic classes. Also bringing these areas together was his work on the geometric theory of the theta function and Kähler geometry.
Together with Dieudonné and others, Weil wrote under the name Nicolas Bourbaki, a project they began in the 1930s, in which they attempted to give a unified description of mathematics. The purpose was to reverse a trend which they disliked, namely that of a lack of rigour in mathematics. The influence of Bourbaki has been great over many years but it is now less important since it has basically succeeded in its aim of promoting rigour and abstraction.
Weil made a major contribution through his books that include Arithmétique et géométrie sur les variétés algébriques Ⓣ (1935), Sur les espaces à structure uniforme et sur la topologie générale Ⓣ (1937), L'intégration dans les groupes topologiques et ses applications Ⓣ (1940), Foundations of Algebraic Geometry (1946), Sur les courbes algébriques et les variétés qui s'en déduisent Ⓣ (1948), Variétés abéliennes et courbes algébriques Ⓣ (1948), Introduction à l'étude des variétés kählériennes Ⓣ (1958), Discontinuous subgroups of classical groups (1958), Adeles and algebraic groups (1961), Basic number theory (1967), Dirichlet Series and Automorphic Forms (1971), Essais historiques sur la théorie des nombres Ⓣ (1975), Elliptic Functions According to Eisenstein and Kronecker (1976), (with Maxwell Rosenlicht) Number Theory for Beginners (1979), Adeles and Algebraic Groups (1982), Number Theory: An Approach Through History From Hammurapi to Legendre (1984), and Correspondance entre Henri Cartan et André Weil Ⓣ (1928-1991) (2011).
$$
For extracts from reviews of some of these books see THIS LINK.
For some extracts from two of Weil's books on the history of mathematics see THIS LINK.
For some extracts from Weil's thoughts on the teaching of mathematics and the future of mathematics see THIS LINK.
Weil received many honours for his outstanding mathematics. Among these has been honorary membership of the London Mathematical Society in 1959 and election to a Fellowship of the Royal Society of London in 1966. In addition he has been elected to the Academy of Sciences in Paris and to the National Academy of Sciences in the United States. He refused to accept honorary doctorates which explains why there are none for us to list.
Weil was an invited speaker at the International Congress of Mathematicians in 1950 at Harvard when he gave an address on Number Theory and Algebraic Geometry and again at the following International Congress in 1954 in Amsterdam when he gave the lecture Abstract versus Classical Algebraic Geometry. In 1979 Weil was awarded the Wolf Prize and, in the following year, the American Mathematical Society awarded him their Steele Prize. In 1994 he received the Kyoto Prize from the Inamori Foundation of Japan:-
... for outstanding achievement and creativity.The citation for the Kyoto Prize reads:-
The results achieved and problems raised by André Weil through his deep understanding of and sharp insight into mathematical sciences in general will continue to have immeasurable influence on the development of mathematical sciences, and to contribute greatly to the development of science, as well as the deepening and uplifting of the human spirit.He is described by Goro Shimura as follows in [49]:-
In my mind, however, he will remain chiefly as the figure with two mutually related characteristics: First, he was flexible and receptive to new ideas of others and new directions, quite unlike many of the younger people these days who can work only within a well-established framework. Second, more importantly and in a similar vein, he had a deep and penetrating understanding of mathematics, or, rather, he strived tirelessly to understand the real meaning of every basic mathematical phenomenon and to present it in a clearer form and in a better perspective. He did so by endowing each subject with new concepts and setting up new frameworks, always in a fresh and fundamental way. In other words, he was not a mere problem solver.Komaravolu Chandrasekharan writes in [14]:-
He was known for his short temper and for his sudden, provocative interventions, which sometimes resulted in abrasive confrontations. That was the less endearing side of his personality. It is in his writings that his personality really shows through - as a master of style, with deep reserves of reading, reflection, and self-scrutiny, with a hotline to the creative imagination.
References (show)
- C McLarty, Biography in Dictionary of Scientific Biography (New York 1970-1990). See THIS LINK.
- Biography in Encyclopaedia Britannica. http://www.britannica.com/biography/Andre-Weil
- H Cartan and A Weil, Correspondance entre Henri Cartan et André Weil (1928-1991) (Société Mathématique de France, Paris, 2011).
- M Mashaal, Bourbaki : une société secréte de mathématiciens (American Mathematical Society, Providence R.I., 2006).
- A Weil, Souvenirs d'Apprentissage (Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, 1991).
- A Weil, The apprenticeship of a mathematician (Birkhäuser Verlag, Basel, 1992).
- S Weil, At Home with Andre and Simone Weil (Northwestern Press, 2010).
- M H Atiyah, Review: Introduction à l'étude des Variétés Kählériennes, by André Weil, The Mathematical Gazette 44 (347) (1960), 78.
- M Audin, Review: At Home with Andre and Simone Weil, by S Weil, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 58 (5) (2011), 697-698.
- A Borel, André Weil (6 May 1906 - 6 August 1998). http://www.math.sunysb.edu/~aknapp/BorelOnWeil.pdf
- A Borel, André Weil, 6 May 1906 - 6 August 1998, Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 145 (1) (2001), 107-114.
- A Borel, André Weil, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (2009), 661-666.
- A Borel, André Weil and Algebraic Topology, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (1999), 422-427. http://www.ams.org/notices/199904/borel.pdf
- A Borel, P Cartier, K Chandrasekharan, S-S Chern and S Iyanaga, André Weil (1906-1998), Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (1999), 440-447. http://www.ams.org/notices/199904/mem-weil.pdf
- A Borel, André Weil: quelques souvenirs, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 37-41.
- A Borel, André Weil and algebraic topology, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 63-74.
- F Burkhart, Andre Weil, Who Reshaped Mathematics, Is Dead at 92, New York Times (10 August 1998).
- R Calinger, Review: Number theory. An approach through history: From Hammurapi to Legendre, by André Weil, Isis 77 (1) (1986), 153-154.
- H Cartan, André Weil, souvenirs d'une longue amitié, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 3-7.
- H Cartan, André Weil: memories of a long friendship, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (6) (1999), 633-636.
- P Cartier, André Weil (1906-1998): Adieu à un ami, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 13-35.
- P Cartier, Abschied von einem Freund: André Weil (1906-1998), Mitt. Dtsch. Math. -Ver. 1999 (3) (1999), 7-12.
- S-S Chern, Review: Variétés abéliennes et courbes algébriques, by André Weil, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 56 (1950), 202-204.
- L Clozel and L Illusie, André Weil (1906-1998) (French), Gaz. Math. No. 78 (1998), 88-91.
- C Corrales Rodriganez, André Weil [1906-1998] (Spanish), Gac. R. Soc. Mat. Esp. 2 (1) (1999), 87-91.
- J E Cremona, Review: Souvenirs d'Apprentissage, by André Weil, The Mathematical Gazette 77 (479) (1993), 261-263.
- M Demazure and M Andler, Entretien avec André Weil, Gaz. Math. No. 50 (1991), 3.10.
- H G Diamond, Review: Number theory. An approach through history: From Hammurapi to Legendre, by André Weil, Science. New Series 226 (4682) (1984), 1412.
- M Hindry, 'Arithmétique des courbes algébriques', la thèse d'André Weil, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 43-55.
- W V D Hodge, Review: Foundations of algebraic geometry, by André Weil, Science. New Series 107 (2768) (1948), 75-76.
- P Hoffman, The Lives They Lived: Andre Weil; Numbers Man, New York Times (3 January 1999).
- J Horgan, Profile: Andre Weil - The Last Universal Mathematician, Scientific American 270 (6) (1994), 33-34.
- S Iyanaga, Trois souvenirs, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 9-11.
- T Jackson, Review: Number theory for beginners, by André Weil, The Mathematical Gazette 64 (429) (1980), 219-220.
- A W Knapp, André Weil: A Prologue, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (1999), 434-439. http://www.ams.org/notices/199904/mem-weil-prologue.pdf
- S Landsburg, André Weil: 1906-1998. http://www.landsburg.com/weil.htm
- H Levy, Review: Introduction à l'étude des Variétés Kählériennes, by André Weil, Science. New Series 129 (3356) (1959), 1136-1137.
- S Mac Lane, Review: The apprenticeship of a mathematician, by André Weil, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 28 (1) (1993), 144-147.
- L Martin, 20th Century mathematics - Weil, The Story of Mathematics. http://www.storyofmathematics.com/20th_weil.html
- R A Nowlan, André Weil, A Chronicle of Mathematical People. http://www.robertnowlan.com/pdfs/Weil,%20Andre.pdf
- D Pedoe, Review: Foundations of algebraic geometry, by André Weil, The Mathematical Gazette 31 (297) (1947), 293-294.
- O Pekonen, L'affaire Weil à Helsinki en 1939, Gaz. Math. No. 52 (1992), 13-20.
- M Raynaud, André Weil et les fondements de la géométrie algébrique, Gaz. Math, No. 80, suppl. (1999), 57-61.
- M Raynaud, André Weil and the foundations of algebraic geometry, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (8) (1999), 864-867.
- E Reyssat, Review: Number theory. An approach through history: From Hammurapi to Legendre, by André Weil, Revue d'histoire des sciences 41 (2), Algèbre, Analyse, Topologie. Questions d'histoire et d'interprétation (1988), 218-220.
- P Ribenboim, Review: Number theory. An approach through history: From Hammurapi to Legendre, by André Weil, American Scientist 73 (5) (1985), 489.
- J P Serre, Andre Weil. 6 May 1906 - 6 August 1998: Elected For. Mem. R.S. 1966, Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society 45 (1999), 520-529.
- J P Serre, La vie et l'oeuvre d'André Weil, L'Enseignement Mathématique 45 (1999), 5-16.
- G Shimura, André Weil as I Knew Him, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (1999), 428-433. http://www.ams.org/notices/199904/shimura.pdf
- V S Varadaraja, Review: The apprenticeship of a mathematician, by André Weil, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 46 (4) (1999), 448-456.
- A Weil, Lettre d'André Weil à Henri Cartan, in The mathematical heritage of Élie Cartan, Lyon, 1984, Astérisque 1985 (1985), 5-7.
- A Weil, A 1940 Letter of André Weil on Analogy in Mathematics, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 52 (3) (2005), 334-341.
- A Weil, The Future of Mathematics, Amer. Math. Monthly 57 (5) (1950), 295-306.
- A Weil, Mathematical Teaching in Universities, Amer. Math. Monthly 61 (1) (1954), 34-36.
- Weil receives Kyoto prize, Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 41 (7) (1994), 793-794.
- J H C Whitehead, Review: Sur les espaces à structure uniforme et sur la topologie générale, by André Weil, The Mathematical Gazette 23 (255) (1939), 318-319.
Additional Resources (show)
Other pages about André Weil:
Honours (show)
Cross-references (show)
Written by
J J O'Connor and E F Robertson
Last Update November 2014
Last Update November 2014